http://www.liweddings.com/uploads/gallery/1477321780.jpg (631) 724-3242 Watermill Caterers
4.68 out of 5 based on 166 user ratings.
/ Reviews (166) / Write a Review / 251K VIEWS
(631) 724-3242 www.watermillcaterers.com 711 Smithtown Byp, Smithtown, NY
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
Connect With Us
Total 166 Reviews
  •    2 out of 5 by Mallory

    My wedding was beautiful. Our attendant was helpful. Everything flowed beautifully. HOWEVER, that was all outshined by the DISGUSTING disrespect I faced at the end of the evening. At the beginning of the morning when I was in the bridal suite with my girls, I was informed that the bridal suite would be LOCKED the entire event and we could be relaxed with our belongings. Maria (our bridal attendant) kept on constantly reminding us to please make sure we lcked the door behind us, and several times I needed to request a key to be able to use the room. HOWEVER, half an hour before the reception ended...all of that was tossed aside . Apparently the wedding after ours arrived 'early"...and we were evicted from the bridal suite!! BUT NO ONE WARNED US. my sister (MOH) had gone to take my nephew to the suite to use the restroom to find them unloading all our personal belongings to be left in the middle of the lobby of the venue. MAria continued to get snippy with my sister and yelled 'ALL THIS STUFFF NEEDS TO GET OUT OF HERE" my sister quickly came and got me...and I did not even get to say goodbye to my guests because I was too busy apologizing to my bridal party for this HORRENDOUS violation and disrespect. Credit cards, purses, gifts, cellphones, clothing, ALL OF IT just tossed aside. I could not believe it. I was so disgusted by that TERRIBLE treatment. they got their money and their tips and could not care less about us. Do yourself the favor and GO SOMEWHERE ELSE.

  •    5 out of 5 by Carolyn

    My wedding was on Wednesday 08/31/11 at the Watermill Caterers. It was great!! I had my ceremony and cocktail outside and my Reception in the Astor suite. Overall the Location was perfectly kept. It was clean, the staffs were friendly and very helpful. I started out working with Frank and then Roy.. Both were very good. My guests still talks about my wedding and commended me on the location.. Thank you all.

  •    5 out of 5 by Natasha

    I recently had my wedding at THE WATERMILL- and it was a page out of a fairytale!!! Not only was the staff attentive, the food was out of this world.Months later people are still calling me about my cocktail hour!!!!! My husband and I wanted to eat before we went into cocktail our so our bridal attendant made us plates of food for the bridal suite. Samantha the wedding planner helped me with so much along the way. My invitations were gorgeous, and everybody loved the platter that Samantha helped me pick out for my favor. She had so many great ideas throughout the planning process. The staff was all very nice, and on their toes. Our bridal attendant Gina really went above and beyond in my opinion. Her nickname for the night :MARY POPPINS! I give The Watermill 2 thumbs up... and 5 stars!

  •    2.5 out of 5 by Melissa

    If I could go back and redo it knowing what I know now there would be quite a few things I would change. They made me 4 plates of food, I never got to eat and they never wrapped it up for us. My husband and I had to order pizza to our hotel room bc we were STARVING!

  •    5 out of 5 by Deborah

    I know everyone says that their wedding was the best day of their lives and i too will state the same however, i could not have been more pleased with everything from the moment i woke until packing up and leaving the watermill. wedding planning with their wedding planner was the BEST extra you could ask for. she was a doll, and assisted with invitations, ideas for seating cards, coctail hour suggestions, invitation wording, and Time management!!! the invitations were spectular and done with a great price and within perfect time. ANY questions she was a phone call away. the same was for the venue... ANY question was a phone call away. From the food to the atmosphere indoors and out was the reson why we chose the watermill. we used teh chapel, that to this day my guests are saying how beautiful the chapel room was. i used the whole first floor and it was easy and convient for all my guests to move, go indoors and out and not get or feel lost or confined. the food was DELISH! everything and more we could have asked for. we wanted some extras ie: kosher platter, baby pig, special carving station.. perfect! additionally was had the extra dessert hour... OMG, my husband and i love sweets... this was above and beyond.. but not TOOO much! guests ate plenty, and snacked plenty. if you need a place to remember adn hassle free... definitly the watermill was the best!

X
X
X
Review
X
X
X