http://www.liweddings.com/uploads/gallery/1477321780.jpg (631) 724-3242 Watermill Caterers
4.68 out of 5 based on 166 user ratings.
/ Reviews (166) / Write a Review / 176.7K VIEWS
(631) 724-3242 www.watermillcaterers.com 711 Smithtown Byp, Smithtown, NY
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
  • Watermill Caterers
Connect With Us
Total 166 Reviews
  •    5 out of 5 by Denise

    Everyone at the Watermill was extremely helpful. Alicia my bridal attendant was a dream, everything I needed, she was there to help. From making me a plate at the cocktail hour, to do the bustle on my dress. I would definitely use the Watermill for the next occasion I have!!

  •    3 out of 5 by Mrs. Lloyd

    My wedding was Thursday, 6/17/2010, I enjoyed the Watermill Service until the cocktail hour. During the cocktail hour my husband, bridal party and I were taking pictures. We did not eat nor have the opportunity to taste the cocktail hor'douves 10 minutes before the cocktail hour was sceduled to end, my maitre'D informed us the cocktail hour was about to end. We walked out of the garden area into the cocktail outdoor area to take photos with our guest. The maitre'D reminded us the cocktail hour is over and we had to walk inside of the reception area. My husband, bridal party and I never had a chance to taste the cocktail hor'douves nor take a picture of the guest who did not sit for the first photo. Once we walked inside of the catering hall, the seat placement cards the banquet manager insist has to be in alphabetical order were not displayed on the a table for my guest to take their seat accordingly. As the bride, I personally assigned the seating arrangements, I had to verbally tell my guest which table they were assigned. I then had to look for my assistant for the placement cards because there were too many people for me to direct them to their seats. My biggest complaint, why was I rushed out of the outdoor cocktail area from taking photos if in fact the reception area was not fully ready for my guest and bridal party to enter the area. Also, we had big blow flies in my bridal suite. During the reception, I had my photographer photo shoot my husband and I at each table. In the mist of walking from table to table for a group photo, the MC in which the Watermill recommended "In the Mood Dj" continue to interrupt the photoshoot by calling the bride and groom to the middle of the dance floor. We (the bride and groom) unfortunately did not have a chance to take a group photo of 1 table our guest were at; out of 8 tables of guest we had taken pictures with 7 tables. Not to mention, after we cut the cake, I asked my maitre'D if he could have the kitchen staff wrap a plate of salmon aside for me (the bride) to take home, he replied, "the food is already placed in boxes to give to the meals on wheels". I kept my cool, however I called the Watermill the next day to complain "the amount of money I paid for food/service/gratitivity and taxes the kitchen staff need to ensure the bride/groom and guest should be asked if they would like to take food home. Whatever is left over should be donated to meals on wheels". However, my guest mentioned the cocktail food was phenomenal. As the bride it would have been nice if my husband and I had a chance to taste it.

  •    4.5 out of 5 by Jennifer

    Bridal attendants were great and all of the staff were extremely friendly. The food was really good. Some complaints on the cake we had ,but it was free in our package. I would recommend this catering hall for the price. :)

  •    5 out of 5 by Natalie

    We could not have asked for a better place to hold our wedding. The food was phenomenal, and the service was exquisite.

  •    5 out of 5 by Wendy

    I had absolutely no complaints with the Watermill. Not only did they exceed my expectations, they went above and beyond. My wedding was absolutely gorgeous. Everything about it was perfect. My wedding was three weeks ago and my wedding guests are still calling me telling me how wonderful the food was. It was so perfect!

X
X
X
Review
X
X
X