Posted by CourtandJon
Thanks soooooooo much girls!!!!! We are so confused about what to do right now- every week we change our minds, last week it was forest hills, this week it's astoria, and just an hour ago DH mentioned he may want to stay in the city
Our lease is up in May but they may let us get out early because they think they can actually get more for our apt- and we pay ALOT so I have no idea who would actually pay even more for it- but they seem to think its possible! So anyway, I will keep your girls posted and if you have anymore info on Astoria I would love to hear it! THANKS!!!!!!
well i grew up in astoria but now live in the kew gardens/forest hills area so i can help compare the two places for you.
as far as the commute, astoria is ALOT easier. I know some people say that FH is close to the city and not a bad commute, now its not horrible but at times can be a pain, especially when i grew up in astoria and it was just a 10 min ride to the city. Now to take the train from Forest hills, to me can be annoying sometimes bc longer than what i was used to. THe LIRR is fast into the city but also depends how far you'll live from the LIRR and it will also cost alot more.
If youre looking for an apartment then forest hills is much better. There are condos and co-ops EVERYWHERE. In astoria you didnt have many, recently they have been building alot of new buildings, but i will say that most of those new apartments they are asking for alot of money, for the amount they are asking you might as well buy a house for 500k-600k rather than a small 2 bedroom. In Forest hills theres lots of buildings both high rises and pre-war buildings in all ranges.
Forest hills also has austin street with lots of restaurants and stores and the stores on austin street are soooo much better than the stores on steinway street.
schools are better in FH, but then again with astoria it depends. You do have overcrowded public schools but then again you also have st. johns prep, mcclancy which are good schools so you dont have to go the public school route. But even with public schools in astoria, there are crowded ones, but theres also many other choices they have. My elementary school was small and there were only 2 classes per grade. DH went to a real good magnet school that also wasnt crowded. As far as HS, like i said you have st. johns and McClancy. I went to bryant which i wouldnt suggest, it is overcrowded and so is LIC HS, and i had alot of friends who went to schools in other neighborhoods such as st. francis in bayside or many went to schools in the city. But then again not sure if you'll even live there that long so not sure if its a concern of yours.
Parking, if you live anywhere near austin street then parking REALLY is a nightmare. Since i lived in both places ill say that in FH certain parts are much worse for parking than astoria. And in astoria not all parts are bad with parking, dh grew up by the ditmars area but by the 40's and theres parking everywhere. So if theres houses with garages or parking in the back then keep that in mind bc you'll know there will be alot of spots.
As far as things to do, Forest hills does have alot of restaurants but overall i think astoria has a bit more. Forest hills has some good restaurants and i love going to eat on austin street. But overall all around astoria there are tons of places and theres alot more bars, lounges and cafes in astoria, not sure if thats whats important to you.
Long island city which is right by astoria has changed so much and really a great neighborhood now. Its a young trendy place, and its an environment i would love to live in now. Theres beautiful new buildings everywhere, problem is to find a decent priced one. I saw 1 br apts for $700k which is insane. BUt theres apartments in 2 family houses that you can get at a decent price
I agree with MrsDtobe that it depends on the lifestyle you want. DH and I want to live somewhere that has lots to do, good place for a young couples and somewhere we can just walk to restaurants, go out for drinks. We really are not looking for VERy family oriented environments yet, we have time until then and for now want to have a different lifestyle.