Post New Topic

Black & White Cookie Question

dgirl0114 Posted:

Black & White Cookie Question

Hi, guys,

Ok, you know the wonderful black/white cookies you get at the bakery? Well, my sister loves them. And we're trying to put her baby shower together. She keeps saying she wants a cake with the kind of frosting they put on black/white cookies. She said she's seen it somewhere but can't remember where.

So I was thinking if I can't find that type of cake does anyone know if I would be able to get black/white cookies with pink/blue frosting to give out as favors?
EmberLynn Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

I'm sure if you tell this idea to your local baker or even supermarket bakery they could come up with something for you. I'm sure they can dye the white frosting to pink or blue for the cookies. I remember seeing a cake like that stop and shop. So take a look, makes some calls. See what you can do.

dgirl0114 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

Thanks; I'm going to check with the local bakery and definitely Stop & Shop-they always have great cakes.

rachie Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

IM not too sure where you live but there is a bakery in Oceanside that makes the black and white cakes. I am sure they will use the frosting...

The name of the bakery is

Mario's Bakery
409 Merrick Road Oceanside, NY

(516) 766-0891
dgirl0114 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

Thank you, thank you, thank you!! I know exactly where that bakery is. I'll give them a call.

PeteysBride Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

My mom goes to the Butter Cooky Bakery in Floral Park. There is one in manhasset too. The place is AWESOME. If you call they might be able to tell you if they can do what you like. ANYTHING you buy from them is delicious. Only place I have ever bougth a cake where you SMELL the whipped cream through the box.

I like Shop Rite's cake selection-NJ supermarkets ROOCK LMAo...That and diners. I ahve never seen a B*W cake there though.
dgirl0114 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

Ok, all this talk about bakeries is making me want to go to one RIGHT NOW!!

MrsQ-in2007 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

mmmmmm cake.

Good luck finding what you need!!!
Pinkiegirll07 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question


Posted by PeteysBride

My mom goes to the Butter Cooky Bakery in Floral Park. There is one in manhasset too. The place is AWESOME. If you call they might be able to tell you if they can do what you like. ANYTHING you buy from them is delicious. Only place I have ever bougth a cake where you SMELL the whipped cream through the box.

I like Shop Rite's cake selection-NJ supermarkets ROOCK LMAo...That and diners. I ahve never seen a B*W cake there though.



I love Buttercooky!!!
We get all of our cakes from there too!!
ant n tilde Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

they have those cakes here:

http://www.sugarbunbakeshop.com/

its in howard beach tho.
Cpt2007 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

sounds wonderful........................................ mmmmm cookies!
PeteysBride Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question


Posted by Pinkiegirll07


Posted by PeteysBride

My mom goes to the Butter Cooky Bakery in Floral Park. There is one in manhasset too. The place is AWESOME. If you call they might be able to tell you if they can do what you like. ANYTHING you buy from them is delicious. Only place I have ever bougth a cake where you SMELL the whipped cream through the box.

I like Shop Rite's cake selection-NJ supermarkets ROOCK LMAo...That and diners. I ahve never seen a B*W cake there though.



I love Buttercooky!!!
We get all of our cakes from there too!!



Aren't they THE BEST! Theirs is the only cream I will eat. I usually scrape cream off cakes because I am not into really sweet food, but I LOVE their whipped cream icing!
JennNicole Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

OMGosh... I love Black n White cookies I want the cake NOW!

lol..
I used to take the white side off and give it to my Mom as a little girl but now I give it to my DH!
dgirl0114 Posted:

Re: Black & White Cookie Question

And I used to eat the chocolate half really quick so I could savor the white side!!

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.