Catskills or Hamptons/Montauk?

Soo... DH and I are looking to go away for his bday in a few weeks and I'm trying to decide between Catskills or out East somewhere.

I've only been to the hamptoms once and have never been to montauk. I've also never been to the catskills during the summer months. So my question is what's there to do? Out east is it really just beaches, sailing and fishing?

im pro montauk

---

Posted by Rosalind_75

im pro montauk

---

What's there to do in Montauk? lol

i have no idea

all we do is go to vineyards restaurants and fishing

but thats cause thats what we love to do