Did you eat your cake on your first anniversary?? If so how was it? DH and I just took ours out of the freezer and plan on eating it tonight.
Update: It actually was pretty good. It was a bit dry, but the butter cream and chocolate pudding were still really good.
cindyandkevin
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
Yup, we did, or at least I did. DH couldn't get past the fact that it was a year old, he had a tiny piece but basically I got to eat it all!! And yes, it was still yummy!!
Happy Anniversary!!!
Mikeysgirl
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
We ate our cake when we got back from the honeymoon. It wasn't that tastey so we had a little and threw the rest away.
ruzi777
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
So Laurn, did you & Paul have some Cake??
I am dying to know???
Happybride2005
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
Posted by LitBallerinaGirl
Did you eat your cake on your first anniversary?? If so how was it? DH and I just took ours out of the freezer and plan on eating it tonight.
we took it with us to the poconos. it still tasted yummy
TnOiOnL
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
we definately plan on it!
LitBallerinaGirl
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
Posted by ruzi777
So Laurn, did you & Paul have some Cake??
I am dying to know???
It was actually really funny because for the past month, Paul has been saying that he was scared to try it. well I opened it last night and the kid was so f'ing paranoid it bordered on hysteria! he swore that the frosting had changed colors and that the filling was not good. So, I dug in and it was actually really YUMMY!!! I told Paul to just give it a try and he finally gave in. Gagging, he took a bite and all of a sudden he goes 'WOW this is good give me some more!!!!' Men, so dramatic sometimes.
fallinlove91407
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
our cake was so yummy -- but we carely got to eat it at the reception so I am curious to see how it'll taste a year later we triple wrapped it in saran wrap and then tin foil based on some article I read -- hope it works and tastes ok
angnick
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
I ate it, DH didnt want to get food poisoning!
Ha ha it was fine though!
CaMacho
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
We each took a tiny bite... it had whipped cream in it so I was scared to eat too much of it. It did taste good though!
futuremrsGafforio
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
We plan on eating it, or should I say take a bite!!! I'm scared!!!
joan_db
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
My MIL is saving us 2 slices of our cake, she wants us to have it on our first anniversary...I dunno about that but whatever makes her happy
SillyBeans
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
yes, and it was awful we took one teensy bite each and threw it out
PegaLega
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
We didnt...we took it out at 1 month and we both looked at it and just threw it out. It wasnt that sentimental to us so it didnt matter
BRod-Cheng
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
We ate our cake. It held up well, and tasted just fine. DHwound up eating the whole thing over the next few days after our anniversary.
babygirl71777
Posted:
Member since
Re: For the not so newly wed newlyweds.
I recently tasted my cake and it was awful !!! But i didnt tell DH that so when the one year mark comes hes eatting it 1st LOL cant wait to see his face
