Idol thoughts?

ok girlies, she just started and I'm hating this kristi lee cook country beatles 8 days a week schlockfest.

I think she's going home tomorrow. Who else is hitting the road?

On the flip side, Carly blew it out as usual and my little Amanda sounded awesome IMHO. And she was even SMILING tonight yay!!!

I also have an old lady crush on that Jason Castro kid, he just makes me smile...

I'm watching on tivo so I'm a little behind but people that I didn't care for have now swayed my decision...

i had SO much fun watching Chakezie & normally I didn't care about him.

Love David Cook
Love, love, love, love Carley & Brooke

Even rocker chick who had disappointed me since she started, I finally liked her again tonight

I'm watching michael now (australian guy).....

david hernandez---i was waiting for him to just admit he was a stripper in his video LOL

---

Posted by Colette

ok girlies, she just started and I'm hating this kristi lee cook country beatles 8 days a week schlockfest.

I think she's going home tomorrow. Who else is hitting the road?

On the flip side, Carly blew it out as usual and my little Amanda sounded awesome IMHO. And she was even SMILING tonight yay!!!

I also have an old lady crush on that Jason Castro kid, he just makes me smile...

---

she ruined my wedding song :(

---

Posted by joshisgirl

---

Posted by Colette

ok girlies, she just started and I'm hating this kristi lee cook country beatles 8 days a week schlockfest.

I think she's going home tomorrow. Who else is hitting the road?

On the flip side, Carly blew it out as usual and my little Amanda sounded awesome IMHO. And she was even SMILING tonight yay!!!

I also have an old lady crush on that Jason Castro kid, he just makes me smile...

---

she ruined my wedding song :(

---

OMG you poor thing, i'm so sorry you had to suffer through that!!! Don't worry it was so bad it will go *poof* and never be heard again. Listen to the Beatles version to clear that monstrosity from your brain!!

Kristy Lee was just horrendous - seriously horrible.

Brooke was great, Carly too. Chakezie really had the best overall performance of the night - it was a nice show on his part.

I personally love David Archuleta - he's very sweet and even though tonight wasn't the best performance, he has an awesome voice.

I'm just watching it now (t-vo it), because its a The Beattles songs, it kind of hard to tell who is singing good.... its like...they are just singing kareoke. JMO

---

Posted by Colette

---

Posted by joshisgirl

---

Posted by Colette

ok girlies, she just started and I'm hating this kristi lee cook country beatles 8 days a week schlockfest.

I think she's going home tomorrow. Who else is hitting the road?

On the flip side, Carly blew it out as usual and my little Amanda sounded awesome IMHO. And she was even SMILING tonight yay!!!

I also have an old lady crush on that Jason Castro kid, he just makes me smile...

---

she ruined my wedding song :(

---

OMG you poor thing, i'm so sorry you had to suffer through that!!! Don't worry it was so bad it will go *poof* and never be heard again. Listen to the Beatles version to clear that monstrosity from your brain!!

---

i had to take a drink afterwards!

---

Posted by MrsQ-in2007

Kristy Lee was just horrendous - seriously horrible.

---

I was embararrassed for her. That's how BAD she was. It was PAINFUL

Brooke = overrated. Cute & nice & pretty voice but no range & has yet to impress me. I don't know what Simon sees in her.

I love David Cook but his hair annoys me. It's so greasy looking.

And I could just sit and stare at Michael Johns for days

And I have to agree about Kristi- that was like a hoe down gone bad.

My guess is that either Ramielle (or whatever her name is) or Kristi gets the boot.

OMG!!! I just got done watching it because I had DVR'd it. Kristi Lee Cook was horrible!!! I like country and that sounded terrible!!! Ramiele was incredibly BORING also. I usually like David Hernandez but he was bad also. I would say that one of those 3 will be going home tonight.
I love Michael Johns and David Cook. I also like Carly Smithson and David Archaletta (sp?)

---

Posted by melissankurt07

OMG!!! I just got done watching it because I had DVR'd it. Kristi Lee Cook was horrible!!! I like country and that sounded terrible!!! Ramiele was incredibly BORING also. I usually like David Hernandez but he was bad also. I would say that one of those 3 will be going home tonight.
I love Michael Johns and David Cook. I also like Carly Smithson and David Archaletta (sp?)

---

I have to agree with this analysis . . .

I usually don't care about David Cook but Eleanor Rigby is one of my all time favorite songs....

I love Jason Castro n
I don't think he will win, but I could look at him all night!! I think Brooke is really good, but again don't think she will win. Krisy Lee Cook needs to go home tonight--She was terrible!