Parent Wedding Album - opinions

I am putting together parent wedding albums and am deciding between these two album types. Most of the pictures will be 5x7's with a few 4x6 and a 8x10. Which do you think is nicer?

Choice #1



Album is available in a scrapbook album style with a black library cloth cover. Photographs are kept safe by the black acid-free, lignin-free cardstock pages, separated by sheets of glassine. Each page measures 10½' x 11-5/8'. Overall album dimensions are 12' H x 11' W x 1¼' Spine. 25 pages.

Choice #2



Album is crafted of rich bonded leather with a binding style and spacers that keep pages lying perfectly flat. Includes acid-free and lignin-free buff-colored cardstock lining. Scrapbook measures 14 3/4' x 13' with 12'x 12' usabable space on each page. Holds 30 pages. Cover can be imprinted with one-line gold lettering. I would pick the black colored album.

Thanks for your input.

Re: Parent Wedding Album - opinions

I think I like the first one better, but it looks really good with B&W--i'm not sure if with color pictures I would liek it more than the other or equally.