Post New Topic

Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

christy Posted:

Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

DH and I have not had a lot of free time together lately, so I want to take him out on Saturday for either lunch or dinner at a nice seafood restaurant. Where do you recommend?

I was thinking maybe the snapper inn???

Any suggestions?
Latina511 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

Riverbay..never been but I heard it was good.

I just went to this restaurant called Sea Haven in Lindenhurst, quiet but the food was good and prices were reasonable.
chmlengr Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

Riverbay in Williston Park (I think that's where it is).

There are also a few in City Island that are excellent.
Latina511 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

JP's in City Island and that is Liz's favorite restaurant.

mims107 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

The restaurant at Captain Bills is terrific. Even for land-lovers the food is great, ( had the best steak there I have had in years)

Of course I am biased because I am getting married at their Bayview house, and FH proposed in the restaurant, but hte food is good, and at dinner time it has a nice atmosphere/view
drjenn10 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

Legal Sea Foods at the Walt Whitman Mall
H2O in Smithtown
WINO1 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

oyster bay fiddleheads wonderful , pricey but yummy and great service the owner roams from table to table...

jbella13 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

Captain Bills, food is awesome. I had my wedding there in June. We go there alot the atmosphere and the food is great

allure Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

The Oar House in Patchogue
The food & atmosphere are great
Or you can try The Harbor Crab Co. also located in Patchogue
DaniRN Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

I was going to also recommend the Oar House.
yabbobay Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

Pier 25 on Northern in Bayside is really good according to DH (I don't like seafood) and there is a place on Jericho in Huntingon...west of 110 on the south side...but I don't remember the name of it...

mlp924 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

The Snapper Inn in Oakdale is great!

chmlengr Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

Erica - yes, Pier 25A is great on Northern Blvd in Bayside. I've eaten there lots because hubby works across the street.....

MayDay16 Posted:

Re: Seafood Restaurant Recommendations please...

If you are in Nassau go on a Sunday afternoon all these are right on Reynold Channel and have great sunsets. The best part is if you don't like one you can bar hop to another. You can either dine in or eat al fresco. These are all located in Island Park.

Go to either

Paddy McGee's - great brunch, you sit watching to boats and munch away. Great seafood.

Coyote Grill - Southwestern plus on Sundays they have a band with free admission - food is very good. This Sunday Mystic is playing and the place gets jammed packed! Check them out they are a vendor on this board.

Jordan's Lobster - a great lobster bar, very good and cheap

Montego Bay - more of a hang out bar, the food is so so

Bridgeview - When not having a wedding this is usually open but its a younger clubby crowd.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.