Sorry I'm late! IDOL

overall, i think arch did great tonite, loved his first song! his second song was upbeat which i liked from him but it was a little embarrassing to hear him say 'boo.' his last song was a bad farty folk song but he sang it beautifully.

syesha looked gorg tonite. has a pretty voice but still consistently underwhelms me.

and cook did good tonite too. i love him and hope he wins, but i felt like he was a bit off tonite. i love that switchfoot song and expected it to be amazing sang by him....not so much.

---

Posted by Colette


Caroline are you on youtube anywhere?? We'd love to hear you SING!!!!!!

---

i was thinking the same thing!

---

Posted by Colette

Man I just don't know who's going... But I think its an all David final???

---

I think u are probably right.

I can't stand David A. His song choices always make me scratch my head. That boy can SING no doubt... but he should be singing for Disney not for pop stardom, not yet anyway...

Syesha should have gone home weeks ago... she's got an amazing voice (sometimes) but she is not the next 'Pop Star' she really would do much better on Broadway and I think her song choice for tonight proved it. I've been waiting all season for her to 'prove us wrong' and just hard core push it with the pop or at least non show tune type performance and then what does she do? Final 3 and she picks Fever... and does a 'chair performance'?? Simon was dead on with the bad cabaret comment.

I felt like David Cook wasn't as good as usual, but still did really well. Do his eyes creep anyone else out? I'm convinced he's got no soul b/c he sold it to win American Idol

This episode was just kinda 'meh' for me.

---

Posted by bemyyoko


I felt like David Cook wasn't as good as usual, but still did really well. Do his eyes creep anyone else out?

---

yep, i call him killer clown.

---

Posted by Aug07OFCbride

---

Posted by bemyyoko


I felt like David Cook wasn't as good as usual, but still did really well. Do his eyes creep anyone else out?

---

yep, i call him killer clown.

---

I'm terrified of clowns
you may have just changed who I want to win lol

---

Posted by bemyyoko

---

Posted by Aug07OFCbride

---

Posted by bemyyoko


I felt like David Cook wasn't as good as usual, but still did really well. Do his eyes creep anyone else out?

---

yep, i call him killer clown.

---

I'm terrified of clowns
you may have just changed who I want to win lol

---

haha. ill still vote for his killer clown face..his voice is THAT good.

i wanted to post a pic of a killer clown here, but i know that would freak to many ppl out so ill spare ya.

---

Posted by Songstress

David Archuleta does not have that star quality to me. He seems like a little gay robot.

---

sorry im so bored tonite boards are slowwwwwwwwww.

---

Posted by Aug07OFCbride

---

Posted by Songstress

David Archuleta does not have that star quality to me. He seems like a little gay robot.

---

sorry im so bored tonite boards are slowwwwwwwwww.

---

THATS HIM!!

---

Posted by Aug07OFCbride

---

Posted by Colette


Caroline are you on youtube anywhere?? We'd love to hear you SING!!!!!!

---

i was thinking the same thing!

---

I'll see what I can find for you. I don't think there;s anything on you tube....