Who saw P.S. I Love You?

omg, how good was that movie? DH and I just watched it tonite and LOVED it. Had us laughing and crying. So well acted.

And can i just say...

GERARD BUTLER..holy molyyyy I went gaga over him when I saw him in 'Dear Frankie' (another good flick..has anyone seen?). what a cutie!!!

i read the book (such a good book). i've kinda been shying away from the movie though, cause the clips i've seen haven't been exactly true to the book plot.....i'll eventually see it though, glad that you say it was good. that makes me feel better.

yea thats gotta be hard for peeps who read books first and then the movies aren't true to the book.

but like i said, it was very well acted IMO! very touching.

Loved it! Now thats what I call romance!

So here's my 2cents...I thought the movie was ok...I LOVED parts and was turned off on many parts, but while I was watching it everytime Joe walked into the room I would start crying! It was horrible. He left to go out with his friends and I was just sobbing when he kissed me goodbye! I could not control it!!! I didn't cry at all during the movie, but one look at Joe or just hearing his voice sent me into an emotional tail spin

---

Posted by amytee

i read the book (such a good book). i've kinda been shying away from the movie though, cause the clips i've seen haven't been exactly true to the book plot.....i'll eventually see it though, glad that you say it was good. that makes me feel better.

---

same here. I love Gerard but still POed at him for taking the Phantom role. He is NIiiiiice on the eyes but didn't have the pipes for the role.

another reason I was turned off was that it was starring HIlary Swank and though I respect her as an actress, I just felt if they cast her they shouldn't cast the super hunky heartthrob opposite her just like when she starred opposite Patrick Dempsey. She's attractive but she's an ordinary kind of pretty and they shouldnt have put the 'Peoples Most beautiful' men opposite. Shallow I know lol

---

Posted by PeteysBride

another reason I was turned off was that it was starring HIlary Swank and though I respect her as an actress, I just felt if they cast her they shouldn't cast the super hunky heartthrob opposite her just like when she starred opposite Patrick Dempsey. She's attractive but she's an ordinary kind of pretty and they shouldnt have put the 'Peoples Most beautiful' men opposite. Shallow I know lol

---

I thought that was one of the great aspects of the movie.. I read it as a sort of Cinderella Story. It's also another nice 'beauty is in the eye of the beholder' lesson

---

Posted by PeteysBride

another reason I was turned off was that it was starring HIlary Swank and though I respect her as an actress, I just felt if they cast her they shouldn't cast the super hunky heartthrob opposite her just like when she starred opposite Patrick Dempsey. She's attractive but she's an ordinary kind of pretty and they shouldnt have put the 'Peoples Most beautiful' men opposite. Shallow I know lol

---

Yup shallow. You aren't the person doing the casting. They felt they could do this role just fine. I don't think caring whether someone was on Peoples Most beautiful list was a concern of theirs

---

Posted by apriladam9206

---

Posted by PeteysBride

another reason I was turned off was that it was starring HIlary Swank and though I respect her as an actress, I just felt if they cast her they shouldn't cast the super hunky heartthrob opposite her just like when she starred opposite Patrick Dempsey. She's attractive but she's an ordinary kind of pretty and they shouldnt have put the 'Peoples Most beautiful' men opposite. Shallow I know lol

---

Yup shallow. You aren't the person doing the casting. They felt they could do this role just fine. I don't think caring whether someone was on Peoples Most beautiful list was a concern of theirs

---

Personally, I would at the chance to have a 2 time oscar winner in my movie.

---

Posted by carolinep24

---

Posted by apriladam9206

---

Posted by PeteysBride

another reason I was turned off was that it was starring HIlary Swank and though I respect her as an actress, I just felt if they cast her they shouldn't cast the super hunky heartthrob opposite her just like when she starred opposite Patrick Dempsey. She's attractive but she's an ordinary kind of pretty and they shouldnt have put the 'Peoples Most beautiful' men opposite. Shallow I know lol

---

Yup shallow. You aren't the person doing the casting. They felt they could do this role just fine. I don't think caring whether someone was on Peoples Most beautiful list was a concern of theirs

---

Personally, I would at the chance to have a 2 time oscar winner in my movie.

---

Exactly

---

Posted by Aug07OFCbride

omg, how good was that movie? DH and I just watched it tonite and LOVED it. Had us laughing and crying. So well acted.

And can i just say...

GERARD BUTLER..holy molyyyy I went gaga over him when I saw him in 'Dear Frankie' (another good flick..has anyone seen?). what a cutie!!!

---

Jess I didn't see 'Dear Frankie.' Whats that one about?

---

Posted by PeteysBride

Can we say RWAR much? As I said, she is a good actress and maybe when I see the movie I will see chemistry between them but based on the book, Hilary Swank doesn't fit the main heroine. And yes thats my opinion. Usually happens if I read a book before the movie.

---

I was just agreeing with what you said was shallow. No need to RWAR

---

Posted by apriladam9206

---

Posted by PeteysBride

Can we say RWAR much? As I said, she is a good actress and maybe when I see the movie I will see chemistry between them but based on the book, Hilary Swank doesn't fit the main heroine. And yes thats my opinion. Usually happens if I read a book before the movie.

---

I was just agreeing with what you said was shallow. No need to RWAR

---

And I was being funny or attempting to be. You went off on the casting. But we all do it with books if we read them first-you kinda create your own idea of the characters in your mind so when you see what someone else's interpetation is, sometimes it causes because we all think diff. According to the book, she doesn't seem to fit. Neither did he but again interpetation.

OMG !!!!! I SAW THIS ON THE PLANE ON OUR WAY TO HAWAII FOR OUR HM!!!!

I WAS HYSTERICAL CRYING ON THE PLANE!!!!

That was probably the WORST movie I could have possibly watched

I was literally snotting on myself! Dan was hysterical laughing at me because every time he turned around i was crying again

---

Posted by soon2bmrsVPT

---

Posted by PeteysBride

another reason I was turned off was that it was starring HIlary Swank and though I respect her as an actress, I just felt if they cast her they shouldn't cast the super hunky heartthrob opposite her just like when she starred opposite Patrick Dempsey. She's attractive but she's an ordinary kind of pretty and they shouldnt have put the 'Peoples Most beautiful' men opposite. Shallow I know lol

---

I thought that was one of the great aspects of the movie.. I read it as a sort of Cinderella Story. It's also another nice 'beauty is in the eye of the beholder' lesson

---

ditto

you have to see it jenn. their chemistry was amazing IMO!!!! and there were so many times when DH and I would look at her and say she looked just really beautiful and other times, id notice her peculiar features. i never really enjoyed her very much but her acting job in this was fantastic and so believable!!! one scene in particular w/ her mom..i \won't give details, DH and I were bawling.