American Idol

---

Posted by Goldi1021

I think I was George Huff's only fan.

I bet anything they introduce NIKKO as the luckiest man in the world. Wouldnt it be something if he walked away with the big prize and won? Assuming Nadia and Anwar were unexpectedly missing.

---

I liked George, but he was my dad's favorite!

---

Posted by Goldi1021

I think I was George Huff's only fan.

I bet anything they introduce NIKKO as the luckiest man in the world. Wouldnt it be something if he walked away with the big prize and won? Assuming Nadia and Anwar were unexpectedly missing.

---

Nope, I LOVED George too!!

Cannot wait to see Nikko!

And I thought Bo ROCKED (and no, I was not referring to him as one of the 'rockers' )

Carrie is SO AWESOME! They were SO mean to her except for Simon and Simon is SO right

Carrie sounded like a huge pile of dog dooky!!!! Sorry, but she did not sing that song well at all. I liked her last week, but not tonight.

---

Posted by Goldi1021

Is it me, or is Carrie a perfect combo of Kelly Clarkson and Reese Witherspoon?

---

I see it totally . . .

---

Posted by heidla

Carrie sounded like a huge pile of dog dooky!!!!

---

Heidi, I gotta agree.. I just don't see what is so special about her at ALL (but Simon is so enamored of her!! )

---

Posted by heidla

Carrie sounded like a huge pile of dog dooky!!!!

---

Don't hold back - tell us how you really feel!

---

Posted by heidla

Carrie sounded like a huge pile of dog dooky!!!!

---

Wow . . . I am surprised . . . everyone is entitled to their opinions, but I kind of feel that Carrie is just very good- I don't see what there isn't to like . . .


My favorites are Bo, Carrie and Constantine . . .

I thought Bo and Nadia were the best performances tonight

Right now though, overall my faves are: Bo, Nadia, Anwar and Constantine ()

Really outside of Nadia, NONE of the girls impress me at ALL

Go Men!!

who do u think we'll be off after tomorrow

---

Posted by Goldi1021

---

Posted by heidla

Carrie sounded like a huge pile of dog dooky!!!!

---

Don't hold back - tell us how you really feel!

---

I don't hold back. I call it like I see it. Maybe I am a little extra opinionated because you can walk into the bar where I work and hear better rendition of most of these songs any night of the week.

---

Posted by heidla

---

Posted by Goldi1021

---

Posted by heidla

Carrie sounded like a huge pile of dog dooky!!!!

---

Don't hold back - tell us how you really feel!

---

I don't hold back. I call it like I see it. Maybe I am a little extra opinionated because you can walk into the bar where I work and hear better rendition of most of these songs any night of the week.

---

Your opinion is fine. I just like your word usage. I hadnt seen the word 'dooky' in ages.

---

Posted by FeliciaDA

I thought Bo and Nadia were the best performances tonight

Right now though, overall my faves are: Bo, Nadia, Anwar and Constantine ()

Really outside of Nadia, NONE of the girls impress me at ALL

Go Men!!

---

I have the exact same favorites.


I really hope Lindsay goes tomorrow!

---

Posted by Happybride2005

who do u think we'll be off after tomorrow

---

Mikayla (fingers crossed) maybe Nikko- or that girl that Simon says has the look but not the talent . . .

ETA- Lindsay- thanks for the reminder

---

Posted by Jax430

---

Posted by FeliciaDA

I thought Bo and Nadia were the best performances tonight

Right now though, overall my faves are: Bo, Nadia, Anwar and Constantine ()

Really outside of Nadia, NONE of the girls impress me at ALL

Go Men!!

---

I have the exact same favorites.


I really hope Lindsay goes tomorrow!

---

GMTA

I totally agree re:Lindsay .. I hope she's outta there!

---

Posted by Goldi1021

Your opinion is fine. I just like your word usage. I hadnt seen the word 'dooky' in ages.

---

I have no idea why I chose that word. I guess I was trying to keep it clean.