American Idol

WOw, Scotts doing awesome!

And a fave song of mine!!!!

omg this song that scot is singing is bringing me back to my wedding!

---

Posted by Jax430

He has hit a few really bad notes. I love this song though.

---

agreed

ooh, he did not do good on that song..I thought he was good in tebh beginning..or maybe its cuz I Love that song that much!

---

Posted by holly231

WOw, Scotts doing awesome!

And a fave song of mine!!!!

---

every time i hear this song i cry;
i actually think he did really well...and better than he has in a while

I dislike Scott and if he doesn't go soon I don't know what I'm going to do.

Bo is the man!!!!

I predict what Simon said about Scott, he will be leaving tomorrow.

---

Posted by Jax430

Goldi, are you around?

---

Sorry Jax. I was not able to watch tonight. we had to ask a friend and her kids to be in our bridal party as bridesmaid, flowergirl and ring bearer!

Carrie...she sounded ok but not great at all.

Bo...He was much better again this week! Although I think he would have sounded better singing the song Constantine chose.

Vonzell...i thought tonight was her weakest performance yet. Not good at all.

Anthony...I thought tonight he did AWESOME! he has a very strong voice!

Constantine..one of my faves but not good tonight..bad choice of song for him.

Scott...needs to go..NOW! I didnt like his performance at all tonight.

Bottom 3 for tomorrow...

Scott
Vonzell
Carrie

ugh...I sooo missed AI last night

What were the songs that Bo & Constantine sang?

---

Posted by HearzBellz

ugh...I sooo missed AI last night

What were the songs that Bo & Constantine sang?

---

Bo sang that Gavin DeGraw song 'I don't wanna be anything other than what I've been trying to be lately.' Constantine sang Nickelback, but I can't remember the song off the top of my head. It was a popular one.

I'm hoping Scott goes home tonight.

hmm...my bottom 3 guesses...
Scott
Anthony
Carrie

---

Posted by lilacwine

I'm hoping Scott goes home tonight.

hmm...my bottom 3 guesses...
Scott
Anthony
Carrie

---

My same bottom three! I also think it will be Scott to go home tonight.

SCOTT MUST GO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I thought Bo ROCKED!!!! My son was so happy he loves that song!!

I also thought Carrie was fantastic. She could of release that song!!!

Constantine- Wasn't that great. I just hate his stage mannerisms. The staring into the camera is getting beyond stalker creeping looking.

Vonzelle-was disappointing this week.

Anthony surprised the hell out of me. He was GREAT!!

My nutshell reviews:

Carrie: Mehhhh. DH looked up at the TV and said, 'That song sure has a lot of words in it.' Later, he asked, 'Did she sing something about high heeled shoes? And gravy?'

Bo: Looked like a junior high school student dressed as a 'hippie' for Halloween, but pretty loveable. Sweet microphone stand moves!

Vonzell: That girl has some pipes. She gets better every week. And she delivers the mail! Did we mention that she delivers the mail?

A-Fed: When I heard he was going to sing a Celine song, I almost had to leave the room for a while. He was better than I expected he'd be (not saying much) and his parents are way cute. Did we mention that he's from the Ukraine? Did we mention his tracheotomy? Did we?

Constantine: The camera loves him, and/or he loves the camera. His chin troubles me. Doesn't that song have some high notes that he didn't even try to hit?

Scott: Will go postal when he is finally eliminated this week. And he doesn't even deliver the mail! Incredibly awful.

Could someone from Ohio please clarify the 'Shaker Heights' situation? I could swear I've heard that SH is one of the wealthiest towns in the U.S., but Scott (and his family) are really playing that 'wrong side of the tracks' crap HARD.

OMG SCOTT MUST GO!! He was horrible last night. His voice sounded like he was going through puberty with all the cracks.

My bottom 3 votes:

SCOTT
Anthony
Constantine (I can't stand how he makes love to the cameras)