American Idol

Re: American Idol

CLAY MADE IT!!!!!!!!!!!! YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: American Idol

I didn't get to see it tonight? Who made it and what was this surprise twist they were talking about?

Re: American Idol

i love clay!! I Also like that kimberly caldwell girl--seems like a sweetie--

Re: American Idol

I was happy Clay won too, but what as Simon thinking when he pushed Carmen in. I didnt think she was that great.
I have to say , I do like Simon, and he has truth to what he says, but not on this one

Re: American Idol

I didn't think that Carmen was all that great. But Simon liked her
Yea Clay!

Re: American Idol

I was so happy that Clay made it to the final 12. What a voice he has!!!

Re: American Idol

I could not believe that Simon picked Carmen. That was a shocker.