American Idol

I keep forgetting its on. I just put it on now.

I still dont know all the contestants. The only one I know is Clay. I think he has a great voice

holy crap - Paula said something negative

OMG Simon told clay his song was aweful.

I thought he was great, I think he is the best

edited to add: 2 weeks ago Simon said Clay is the one to beat

wow--interesting night---i think Simon is just not getting the past two weeks genre--between the country and then this week with the Disco--i don't think the Brits are into that kind of music! LOL i was l glad they addressed the corey clark issue but's he's dumb 'pleading' not guilty on national TV--whatever---

I loved Clay--he sounded great depsite the fact that this is totally not his type of music!

i felt so bad for Josh Gracin-he is so cute but he did sound awful tonight -- the poor kid probably has bigger things on his mind- like UM WAR maybe-

kimberely locke has a good voice but needs new clothes---

my opinion of trenyce has been altered since i heard she has a 'record' (and i use that term loosely--) doesn't change the fact that she has an amazing voice and talent though, and she's beautfiul--

i like carmen-i don't know why everyone is so against her--Simon sure loves her because he picked her! LOL

Ricky was so funny with that afro and i thought he did really well--

RUUUUBEN was so adorable-he did AWESOME!

Kimberely Caldwell did well also-I like her-i think she's the real deal--

I, too was shocked when Paula said some negative things--
sorry this is so long! LOL btw, i think it's so dumb that they make them sing all different genres--when you are famous and happen to make it big-you don't have to prove yourself in all categories--but i guess that's just the nature of the competition!

Is it just me....or does anyone else NOT see what's so special about Ruben? I don't think he's that great. JMO!!
I love Clay, he has the best voice by far, BUT, I don't think he necessarily fits the part as a pop star. He would be GREAT on Broadway though!

I am so glad Corey is gone...hee hee, he was awful.

I'm also in SHOCK that Paula sad something negative....very rare! She is starting to annoy me, as is Randy (what up DAWG? Yeah, man....). But hey, I'm 9 months pregnant and maybe I'm moody!

Ricky was ok, he will be eliminated

The 17 yr old, now 18 was good

Kimberly C was great

Ruuben lived up to his standards, he was fantastic, so smooth, like butta...LOL

Trenyce was ok

The marine guy has to go

The 2nd Kimberly was good

We will see how America votes tomorrow

I forgot Clay he needs to learn how to dance but he was good.

I wasn't to impressed tonigt. Simon was grumpy and even Paula wasny' really liking it that much - she didn't even agree with Randy for a change.
Rickey did okay
Carmen I thought did very well
Kimberly C was okay
Clay was really good
Reuben was really good
Trenyce I think always sings Whitney songs, but overall good
Kimberly L was okay. I feel she yells whenshe sings
Josh was out of it. He could do better

My pick for the bottom 3 tomorrow is Kimberly C, Ricky and Josh

JMO

Well, I was impressed with Corey's apology. I did not think that they would mention it like that and just assume that the audience knew what happened... but I thought it was good that they explained it.

Here's my thoughts:

* Ricky - the best I've seen him do since it started
* Carmen - OK
* Kimberly C - pretty good
* Clay - good singer, I just don't feel it with him
* Reuben - eh, I'm not seeing what everyone else sees
* Trenyce - ok, I thought she sounded really good, but didn't understand how that fit with Disco, I guess I'm out of it
* Kimberly L - I REALLY like her
* Josh - poor guy, not feeling well today... it's going to ruin him I really liked him too!

My bottom three - Josh, Kimberly C, and Trenyce with Josh leaving...

Ricky - Though I don't like him I thought he was good.

Carmen - OK

Kimberly C -I really liked her

Clay - good singer, But he has to learn to move around.

Reuben - I love him!!! I thought he was great.

Trenyce - She annoys the tick out of me!! She sounded like she was trying to impersonate Whitney Houston. She's got to go!!

Kimberly L - I liked her. The only thing I can say is she need to purchase tummy tucker underwear!

Josh-I'm a BIG fan of him. I was so upset that he chose that song. I HATE IT!!

And how freaky is Mr. Earth Wind & Fire???? Cut that hair. Also if he got any closer to Ryan they would of been smooching!

The marine had to go 2 weeks ago.

Clay is always my favorite. Tonights song just wasnt him. He wasnt feeling it, but no matter he's got a great voice. he's gonna go far

Trenyce I thought was good. I like her

I dont remember the others.

My bets:
Kimberly C, Ricky and Josh are going to be in the bottom 3
I really think Josh will be the next to go though...

I was so mad...I FELL ASLEEP

I heard Ricky and Carmen and missed everyone else

IrishTracy - I totally agree - That EWF guy was creepy!!
I felt so bad for Josh - He was really horrible. I was cringing the whole time he was up there - I didn't even want to hear what the judges had to say.
I really think Carmen stinks - She sounds like a sheep when she sings with that overdone vibrato!
I thought the 2nd Kimberly was really good. She usually doesn't look great but I thought she looked the best I've ever seen her last night.
As for the bottom three, I definitely think it will be Ricky, Josh and Kimberly C. I think Kimberly will be voted off, though. She's been the bottom three the past few weeks so I think it's her time to go.
Melissa27 - My DH doesn't think Reuben is good either. I really think what makes him good is his personality but my DH doesn't see it -

I missed the performances of Ricky and Josh, but from the recap at the end, Ricky seemed good, and Josh seemed awful, poor guy, probably has a lot on his mind

Onto those I saw:

Carmen: sorry but Len and I both thought she was horrible. I think she should go next.

Kimberly C - pretty good

CLay - perfect voice, as usual, but he does need to shake that l'il bootie of his

Reuben - smooth singer as usual, with his dimples. I really like his confidence and smile

Trenyce - good singer, although something about last nights performance bothered me. I can't quite place it

Kimberly L - good, I must agree, a little tummy tucker hose was in order

o man-that EW&F dude really freaked me out too-last night was just not one of the best shows i've seen-does anyone know what next week's theme/genre is?