American Idol...

Original post by Stacey1403

Apr 29, 2003 07:57 PM

...is on now!!!! ( move over Ryan Seacrest)

IrishTracy Posted: Apr 29, 2003 09:03 PM

Re: American Idol...

I LOVE JOSH!!! But I know he won't win. Trenyce better go before him!!!

Margaret Posted: Apr 29, 2003 09:04 PM

Re: American Idol...

Although I think Josh is adorable, his time has come. I also think his attitude towards Simon was a little immature (even though it is obvious Simon isn't into country).

Treynece (sp?) - I thought tonight was her best.
Kim Locke - Amazing!!! I have always loved her.
Ruben - He is so smooth. He is always good.
Clay's version of Solitude was simply beautiful.

Wendy Posted: Apr 29, 2003 09:21 PM

Re: American Idol...

Margaret I agree with you. I think Josh should go next. He was not at all good tonight and everyone else was awesome.

HeatherandNick Posted: Apr 29, 2003 09:37 PM

Re: American Idol...

I think Josh has sung his last song for the season! He was not good tonight. His 2nd song was okay, but the first was horrible.

The Original 2nd-time-around Posted: Apr 29, 2003 09:40 PM

Re: American Idol...

Yeah, although I'd like Trenyce to be next to go, I think it may be Josh

Stacey1403 Posted: Apr 29, 2003 09:59 PM

Re: American Idol...

Josh is definately out of there

dkga1026 Posted: Apr 29, 2003 10:01 PM

Re: American Idol...

I feel bad for Josh, but it's definitely time for him to go.
Trenyce just annoys me to no end. There's something about her that just rubs me the wrong way, maybe she thinks too much of herself or something.
Of the 3 left, they all deserve to win - they are all very talented and adorable!

shamma Posted: Apr 29, 2003 10:03 PM

Re: American Idol...

I did not see it I was at the mall oh well I will see the boot off show tomorrow

Stacey1403 Posted: Apr 29, 2003 10:17 PM

Re: American Idol...

Shamma you missed a good one. They each got to sing 2 songs

endlessluv429 Posted: Apr 29, 2003 10:23 PM

Re: American Idol...

I'm sorry but josh needs to go--he looks miserable up there--

Kimberly Locke was awesome tonight--she really has grown on me-i think it'll be her, clay & Ruben in the end!

Ruben was great as usual--always consistent

Clay was amazing--he really does take constructive criticism really well & he did get rid of his facial expressions. He did spectacular!

Trenyce was eh-ok-i think her or josh will be voted off next--sorry to say but simon was right about her first outfit! LOL

OctBride03 Posted: Apr 29, 2003 10:29 PM

Re: American Idol...

Okay, here I go!

Ruben - missed the first song But the second was awesome! He's growing on me! Although he's not my favorite.

Trenyce - I REALLY like her voice, but her face annoys me

Josh - poor guy, his time is up... I think he sounds good but as someone said, he looks miserable. He's a country singer and who knows he may make it big that way

Kimberly - What can I say? I LOVE HER!!! I want her to win, but it's going to be tough....

Clay - First song was AWESOME! I LOVED IT!! Second song, EH!

All in all, Josh is going to go tomorrow, then Trenyce, boy is it going to be a tough one when, Kimberly, Ruben and Clay are left!! I think all three are sooooooooo talented!

WishCandy Posted: Apr 30, 2003 08:26 AM

Re: American Idol...

I think that Clay did the best last night! I was so happy for him

LizD Posted: Apr 30, 2003 08:49 AM

Re: American Idol...

I think Ruben and Kimberly did the best last night.
I hate when they do the hour show for the vote off, just tell us who is going home and get on with it!!

Valenia Posted: Apr 30, 2003 09:15 AM

Re: American Idol...

I really wish Kimberly hadn't shown so much attitude/disrepect to the judges in the pre-12 round. I have so much trouble liking her because of that. But yes, she, Clay and Rueben deserve to be the top 3 without question.

nrvbrd Posted: Apr 30, 2003 10:00 AM

Re: American Idol...

I didn't hear Reuben's first song- Was it as bad as Simon said?

I loved Clay and Kinberly as well as Reuben.

Scoop Posted: Apr 30, 2003 10:17 AM

Re: American Idol...

My predictions:

I think Josh is the next to go. He just does not compare to the others.

Trenyce will go after him. I can't stand her. She has way to much confidence to stick around.

Clay will go after her and my final two predictions are Ruben & Kimberly with Ruben taking it all.

michele31 Posted: Apr 30, 2003 10:31 AM

Re: American Idol...

I guess I think that Josh and Trenceye (sp?) are both out of their league up there. The best part of tonight was NOT listening to Carmen sing :D plus Rickie was in the audience.

Rueben, Clay and Kim will be the final 3 and all 3 will end up with contracts. Simon might not like Country BUT I do believe that if he thought someone was doing a good job he would tell them that. You do not have to LIKE a certain type of music to appreciate someone doing it well. Josh is NOT having any fun. He is very inexperienced at performing and it shows. He needs some time to develop his voice,style and personality on stage. T-is too Mariah Diva for me. She ain't all that.