American idol dont read if you havent seen..im livid!

---

Posted by nycchic_24

I am livid!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Scott over Nikko?????????????? Micala over Amanda??????????????? ***!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

---

i feel tht total opposite way....nikko really ***** and he did from the beginnning. and amanda was alright but mikalha was very different.....i thought mickalha and scott definetly deserved the last two postions.....but like everyone says its all up to the voters that call in. so i guess we all cant be that mad.

---

Posted by soon2bmrsp06

the way they are doing it this year it so not right.. every other year the judges picked the top 10 and then we got to pick 2 from the wild card. and it should have been that way this year also ..

---

No, every other year, they broke up into 4 groups of 8 and america voted 2 from each group. There were 4 wild card spots. The judges each got to choose one person, and America voted for 1.

I kind of like it better this year, b/c I remember last year one of the groups of 8 was so bad, and we still had to take two people from that group. Then again, I would rather have had more of the guys from the semi finals than the girls..I don't know how they can break it up in a fair manner...

I agree that Nikko should have stayed, but Amanda annoyed me, especially her tapping the mic while singing

---

Posted by Aga

I agree that Nikko should have stayed, but Amanda annoyed me, especially her tapping the mic while singing

---

That annoyed my SIL (DH's sister) too...LOL...but she still sounded better than Mikala...(a.k.a. Fran Drescher) that's who she sounds and reminds me off...LOL

---

Posted by bedda26

---

Posted by JimmysBride

I was certain it was going to come down to being between Constantine & Scott (besides Travis who of course was going to go). I can't believe that Constantine got through - it should have been him that went home and Nikko should have gone through.

From the girls, I was not surprised at all. Amanda has peaked already and I really didn't think she had much else to offer.

Looking at the top 12 - I have good guesses as to who will be in the bottom three next week and with any luck - Constantine will be the first to go!

---

And mikala has a lot more to offer...with her deep annoying voice????????? It should have been Janay and mikala.

---

I don't know if she's got alot more to offer but at least she's different. I also think what Simon said is true - that people are going to either love her or hate her...and since the haters can't vote her off....

She is a horror...with nothing to offer.

Seriously I don't see any talent in her, other than she looks and sounds like Fran Drescher.

---

Posted by bedda26

Seriously I don't see any talent in her, other than she looks and sounds like Fran Drescher.

---

I'll definitely give you that!!!

---

Posted by JimmysBride

---

Posted by bedda26

Seriously I don't see any talent in her, other than she looks and sounds like Fran Drescher.

---

I'll definitely give you that!!!

---

\
It's true though isn't it? Very freaky.

---

Posted by Aga

I agree that Nikko should have stayed, but Amanda annoyed me, especially her tapping the mic while singing

---

i think my they tap the mike, they count the beats

---

Posted by Happybride2005

---

Posted by Aga

I agree that Nikko should have stayed, but Amanda annoyed me, especially her tapping the mic while singing

---

i think my they tap the mike, they count the beats

---

But how could she not know that her ring on that hand was actually drowning out her voice. I'm very surprised that one of the other contestants or one of the judge's for that matter, didn't try to motion to her to stop.

---

Posted by nycchic_24

I agree Bedda...I dont think she sounded bad..and I truly think Lindsey did in her last performance! Amanda should definately not have been voted off just yet.

---

I couldn't agree more with you. By the way I like what your chat avatar says. I am so ready for summer. I'm even dying for spring!

---

Posted by JimmysBride

I was certain it was going to come down to being between Constantine & Scott (besides Travis who of course was going to go). I can't believe that Constantine got through - it should have been him that went home and Nikko should have gone through.

From the girls, I was not surprised at all. Amanda has peaked already and I really didn't think she had much else to offer.

Looking at the top 12 - I have good guesses as to who will be in the bottom three next week and with any luck - Constantine will be the first to go!

---

I couldn't have agreed more . . .

I personally can't wait until Constantine and Mikayla are gone