American Idol fans-please check in

---

Posted by holly231

I totally think it will be between LaToya and Diana...

I think they both have beautiful and amazing voices

---

I agree 100%!!!!

The whole idea I THOUGHT of the show was to sing a Big Band song! What does Queen or Barbra Streisand have to do w/ big band????

---

Posted by kel2004

Am I the only one who can't stand Fantasia? I hate her voice and her personality.

---

I am with you, I don't like her voice or personality. Her voice reminds me of Macy Gray.

Fantasia does NOT sound like Macy Gray!

I would say 99.9% of the songs they sang last night were not 'big band' songs... but they were stylized with the big band sound- which is fine.. most songs can be sung many different ways.

I really don't like Diana- she has 2 ways of singing--- loud and louder. No emotion, nothing.. I really had to MUTE her last night... hideous.

George also got muted- firstly- 'wonderful world' is so overdone I wanted to barf- PICK A NEW SONG.... secondly- stop BUGGIN' YOUR DAMN EYES OUT.

I agree with you Sassy. George is always bugging his eyes out...I liked him in the beginning but now he's annoying me.

Dianna just reminds me of the 80's when Debbie Gibbson and Tiffany were around. They were both 16 and died out fast, so will she if she wins. I do not want another Gibbson and Tiffany era. Can someone introduce that girl to support hose! she wears these tight outfits and she's has a fat stomach that makes her look horrible in these tight dresses.....seriously she needs support hose or a girdle...she is annoying annoying annoying! Her and Jasmine put me to sleep...one of them should go before george.

I loved fantasia and Latoya. simon was right they are in a class by themselves. I want Latoya to be the winner!

I LOVE GEORGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A tad bit disappointed with him from last night's performance but I still love him. He is such a happy person.

LaToya and Fantasia are my guess for final two!!!!

---

Posted by soon2bMrs

---

Posted by kel2004

Am I the only one who can't stand Fantasia? I hate her voice and her personality.

---

I am with you, I don't like her voice or personality. Her voice reminds me of Macy Gray.

---

ahh! Thank goodness. I thoguht i was alone with that. there are a few songs she has sung really well, but her weird voice is not as versatile as Latoya's.

I'm just afraid LaToya isn't memorable enough..
I think that is b/c the judges loved Jennifer & talked about her, & la Toya was neglected. But now people seem to be noticing.

---

Posted by bedda26

I agree with you Sassy. George is always bugging his eyes out...I liked him in the beginning but now he's annoying me.

---

I totally agree.

---

Posted by bedda26
Dianna just reminds me of the 80's when Debbie Gibbson and Tiffany were around. They were both 16 and died out fast, so will she if she wins. I do not want another Gibbson and Tiffany era. Can someone introduce that girl to support hose! she wears these tight outfits and she's has a fat stomach that makes her look horrible in these tight dresses.....seriously she needs support hose or a girdle...she is annoying annoying annoying!

---

I totally agree about hte support hose!
I keep telling FH she needs a girdle or a differnt outfit or somwthing.
I don't care what size you are , but if you are going to be on tv, get clothes that fit!

I happen to disagree. Latoya's voice is 10 times better than Jennifer's.

I don't understand what the big deal is about Dianna's voice. Her performances NEVER knock me off my feet.

Well said Tourist...

Her outfits are horrible...

---

Posted by bedda26

I happen to disagree. Latoya's voice is 10 times better than Jennifer's.

I don't understand what the big deal is about Dianna's voice. Her performances NEVER knock me off my feet.

---

Oh no, you are totally right, La Toya is much better than Jennifer, but ofr somereason the judges wouldn't shut up about her, that I almost didn't know who Latoya was in the beginning.
Jennifer, like Diana, was a screamer.

I didn't remember her form the semi finals, but after there 2nd or 3rd episode of the finals she was my favorite.

I'm just a flipper though, so I may have missed her in the beginning.

I LOVE LOVE LOVE Latoya!! she better win. she is definetely in a different league-she's much more mature than the others. she has such class. Fantasia annoys me a little, her voice is a little too sqeaky for my taste, she lacks the class to be a star IMO. George needs to go, nice guy, but eh-he can be a little much @ time. he didn't sound too great last night. i really love diana--she has such a sweet stage presence and personality. she is a little pitchy but I like her

I see what Simon was saying about Diana. When she did her second song, she kind of reminded me of a 8-year old girl who has a really good voice that can sound like a much older person, but you can still tell it's a kid's voice.

I think Jasmine or George will be going tonight. I'll be disappointed if it's not Fantasia and Latoya in the top 2 in the end b/c if it's one of them with another person, you know each one'll win over anyone else.

Yes Violet that is so true. Simon was soooooooo right about that.

In my opinion..LATOYA BLOWS everyone else away! She is so talented..noone can even hold a candle next to her...if they were to all have careers and have albums out..I would NOT buy anyones except for Latoya's, they all ahve some talent granted, but Latoya already sounds famous..she doesnt need any work..just my opinion!

If I heard any songs on the radio by George, Dianna or Jasmine I would quickly change the station.....

Ugggh!!! The Thought of Dianna winning turns my stomach. I hate her!!!!!!!!!!!