American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Original post by LizD

Apr 22, 2003 08:45 PM

Finally---Randy basically tells her she is terrible, and Simon tells her she can't win!!

Stacey1403 Posted: Apr 22, 2003 09:17 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

The only thing in Carmen's future is Stridex commercials

The Original 2nd-time-around Posted: Apr 22, 2003 09:19 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

LOL... I can actually see her doing that!

SomedayBride Posted: Apr 22, 2003 09:22 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

She has terrible skin, she needs stridex! With all that makeup, you can still see her breakouts.

LizD Posted: Apr 22, 2003 09:30 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Stacey-- that is so true!! Well, st least she has a future!

Kathi Posted: Apr 22, 2003 09:38 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

I've said it since week 1...Carmen sukks!!! God help me if she makes it through another week. Now that the war is *almost* over, so is Josh's sympathy vote... he's outta there next week. Trenyce will be right behind him!!

It will be interesting to see how Clay, Ruben & Kimberly end up. I can't decide who should win yet!!

Chloegirl Posted: Apr 22, 2003 09:41 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Kimberly is actually inching up the list to being my favorite....in the beginning she was no where near the top of my list!

Carmen just doesnt have it....that is cute about the Stridex comercials....I feel bad for her. Hey she is a teenager!

HeatherandNick Posted: Apr 22, 2003 11:28 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Bye Bye Carmen!

LisaT Posted: Apr 22, 2003 11:55 PM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

I thought Josh was worse than Carmen this week, but they both need to go.

WishCandy Posted: Apr 23, 2003 08:13 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Josh was definitely worse than Carmen by a long shot! I never thought he was that great to begin with tho - he only sang like 2 songs well... it'll be a toss up btwn the 2 for who goes tonight. And did anyone notice that Trenyce missed a few of the words in her song last night and just smiled? Trenyce sucked it up last night as well... she's no Brandy or Whitney

Sassy Posted: Apr 23, 2003 08:17 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

I missed all the festivities.
Wedding planning chaos last night
But at least my sis taped it for me, and i get to see it tomorrow

eroxgirl Posted: Apr 23, 2003 08:45 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

If Carmen doesn't get the boot this week, I think I'll lose it! FH was talking too much so I missed Josh

I'm just afraid because Carmen got trashed by the judges last night (and rightfully so!) she'll get the sympathy vote - but I have to say I was SHOCKED that Randy was so blunt like that - I mean, he's right, of course, but he usually leaves that kind of comment to Simon.

Annie02 Posted: Apr 23, 2003 08:49 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

I also thought Josh was worse than Carmen - I am hoping that he will go tonight!

jcndd Posted: Apr 23, 2003 08:51 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Are Carmen and Clay together? I've heard so much about it and they kissed last week (or was it the week before?? )

AlisonMT Posted: Apr 23, 2003 09:16 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Who was the guest judge last night?

Mary Posted: Apr 23, 2003 09:18 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

I think that Carmen is getting cocky; she's not the sweet little thing she was, and I think it'll hurt her.

shelzyp Posted: Apr 23, 2003 10:05 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

I was telling my FH last night that Treyence, Josh and CArmen all need to be voted off this week.

There is no way that any of them can win!!!

They should be eliminated this week, and lets see the real contestants,

Ruben, Clay and Kimberly!!!!

Thrilled Posted: Apr 23, 2003 10:24 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Okay I'll say it again: For those of you who asked if Clay and Carmen are together, and for all those teenage girls out there holding up 'I love Clay Aiken' signs, I have one word for you all:

Gaydar.

OctBride03 Posted: Apr 23, 2003 10:27 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Well I couldn't post my review last night, soooo here I go:

First of all, Randy and Simon both said what Carmen needs to hear, HOWEVER, they were VERY MEAN about it. I was SHOCKED when Randy came out with that about her, I just thought it was AWFUL. Personally I can't stand Randy, he annoys me, but whatever...

Carmen - Her time is up and the poor girl still thinks she can win this.... I do however think she has the right 'look' to being a pop star. JMO!

Trenyce - I do like the way she sings but it's getting old now, Simon is right when he says she's like singing with a mask on.

Josh - Well maybe not tonight, but his time is running short as well... although the judges do seem to like him.

Clay - He definitely sounded great last night, and he seemed to have improved the way his face looks when he sings... I just don't think he belongs on stage unless it's in a musical.

Ruben - He's growing on me and yes he was great!

KIMBERLY - She is my FAVORITE! I think she sounds awesome every week!!! And I'm so glad she went a little out of her normal routine!

Did you hear Simon tell Ruben that he and Clay should watch out for Kimberly Locke! I got so excited! Okay, I think I'm done now! Sheesh, that was long! Sorry.

WithThisRing Posted: Apr 23, 2003 11:04 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

Carmen needs to go. FI watched it last night and he was ready to change the chanel.

Clay rocked. He always sounds amazing.

Josh needs to go. That song was all wrong for him.

Kimberly also needs to go but only one can go tonight so I am tied on who needs to go

treynce as someone said is tired. she had her moment in the spotlight, its time to go home

ruben as always the best. he and clay to the end.

shamma Posted: Apr 23, 2003 11:30 AM

Re: American Idol - Randy zaps Carmen

The way they have been eliminating boy/girl, boy/girl, tonight its Josh's turn, or they might let Clay or Ruben go, you never know how these fixed programs work.