American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

Original post by The Original 2nd-time-around

Apr 20, 2004 12:15 PM

Barry Manilow is the special guest! I am a closet Barry fan, so I'm pretty excited!!

Jenn524 Posted: Apr 20, 2004 08:51 PM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

and now I can say John Stevens was bad tonight as well. And he should have been able to rock tonight. If he can't do well tonight he needs to go.

heidla Posted: Apr 20, 2004 08:51 PM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

Posted by Mandy77

Barry is the love of my life!!

If that red headed freak sings Mandy I'll be sooooooooooooo upset!!!!

UH OH

heidla Posted: Apr 20, 2004 08:53 PM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

I really thought that everybody so far except LaToya(?) was okay. She has been the only one so far that I thought sounded great. Then again I am a really tough critic.

Jenn524 Posted: Apr 20, 2004 08:53 PM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

Posted by heidla

Posted by Mandy77

Barry is the love of my life!!

If that red headed freak sings Mandy I'll be sooooooooooooo upset!!!!

UH OH

LOL

IrishTracy Posted: Apr 21, 2004 08:46 AM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

My opinions (NOT THAT THEY MATTER)

Diana & Jasmine- Were AMAZING!!

Jennifer & Fantasia-I wasn't thrilled on what they did with the songs.
Though Jennifer sounded great. BUT........the song is supposed to be simple & beautiful!! She was bellowing it out.
Fantasia-I felt like I was in a church!

George-BAD!!!!!

John-Did the best he can (I gotta protect my guy) Mandy is a very hard song to sing. But, it wasn't horrible! (Again MY opinion!! )

bedda26 Posted: Apr 21, 2004 09:22 AM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

John has got to go...it's time. He can't be the winner...please God don't let that happen.

I voted for Jennifer and Latoya last night. Fantasia annoys me!

Mandy77 Posted: Apr 21, 2004 09:43 AM

Re: American Idol tonight (take a look at this IrishTracy!)

I almost threw my tv out the window when I heard my song being destroyed!!!!

I seriously almost had tears in my eyes. That never should have happened!!!