Post New Topic

Bakery and Caterer Review

cluelessbride Posted:

Bakery and Caterer Review

My best friend had her reception on September 20th on Fire Island, with two huge tents, a great dj, and the best foood I have ever had at a wedding!!

Caterer: Michele and Co. They were fabulous. My friend had a raw bar, a 'Tuscan Table' and a table of different meat: marinated steak strips, roast beef, ham. The raw bar was top-notch. I love oysters and have had some not-so tasty ones, but these were so good. The Tuscan table was awesome. If you need an off-site caterer, I highly recommend them.


Bakery: Plain Jane in Sayville. Her cake was chocolate chocolate, and so yummy! How yummy? The person next to me offered me $$$$ for my piece. He started at $20 and went up to $50 and finally I said 'Please stop, you are not getting it!' It was really delicious.

Then the waiters brought out brownies and pecan bars. Yummm!! People were going crazy over them. The day after the wedding my FH and I stopped off at the bakery just to buy more.

NovemberSue Posted:

Re: Bakery and Caterer Review

You're making me hungry! Glad everything was great.
AtticaQT Posted:

Re: Bakery and Caterer Review

WOW!! Money for cake - you should have actioned it off!! *LOL* - highest bidder please- nothing less than $200 - *lol* -

Does Plain Jane have a website?
allure Posted:

Re: Bakery and Caterer Review

Sounds like a great wedding

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.