Post New Topic

Big Cookies

Original post by Toucan311

Totally at a loss as to what to do for favors, I'm thinking maybe a donation to the ASPCA and big cookies shaped like cats & dogs, since I'm a huge animal person. Anyone know where I can get cute cookies like this that taste good and arent insanely expensive? Like ones you have TRIED before and enjoyed eating?

Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

I'm bumping this b/c I have a new question. I looked into Splurge bakery, and it just wasn't in my budget. Anyone know about how much a local bakery (like Alpine or that Manhattan Sweets one in Islip) might charge for a big cookie?

Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

I want something liek those above. I dont want to spend more than $2 a cookie b/c I'm also doing a donation in combination with the cookie.

Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

Bumping! Help!

kimandvin Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

I like that idea.... Love the donation thats what I am doing probably with a bottle of wine

dajc23 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

I'm not sure how much they charge per cookie but you should give Dortoni's in Levittown a call. They are AMAZING, and i've seen so many different cookies all shapes, sizes, designs...they really are very talented

Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

Thanks girls! So many of these places start at $3 per cookie, which kinda defeats my whole purpose b/c I want to spend the bulk of the money on the donation and not the cookie!

Cutechef729 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

Eleni's bakery in Chelsea market does favors and the cupcakes and cookies were delicious. I found a picture of a dog cooke for you to perouse...

Eleni's cookie favors

Sh*t those are so expensive!!! I didn't realize...oops.
Cutechef729 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

What about lollipops? Since my original post was useless, I'm trying to redeem myself lol. The link is for a place but you could also get those lollipop molds from michael's and make a bunch ahead of time and keep them in the fridge?




Bone lollipops


Scottie dogs


Dog shaped
ChristineAaron08 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

FH is giving me some name he thinks they are (donnalicious in sayville) but i dont find anything on google for that name


soo, i havent tried these but they seem to be on the cheaper side.

Maybe you can ask for a sample


http://mckinneysweets.com/cookies.htm
ChristineAaron08 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies


Posted by dajc23

I'm not sure how much they charge per cookie but you should give Dortoni's in Levittown a call. They are AMAZING, and i've seen so many different cookies all shapes, sizes, designs...they really are very talented



i was in there recently and saw their cookie baskets- they were so pretty..im sure they are good b/c everything else I have tried is good there

sor- idk prices though
Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies

Thanks girls! I'll look into all of these things.

Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Big Cookies


Posted by Cutechef729

Eleni's bakery in Chelsea market does favors and the cupcakes and cookies were delicious. I found a picture of a dog cooke for you to perouse...

Eleni's cookie favors

Sh*t those are so expensive!!! I didn't realize...oops.



OMG those are PERFECT but a bit pricey... I lvoe the horse!

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.