Can Anyone Recommend a Nice Restaurant (preferable Italian) on the South Shore? (pref. Western Suffolk)

AndreaLMT Posted: Dec 10, 2004 07:29 PM

Can Anyone Recommend a Nice Restaurant (preferable Italian) on the South Shore? (pref. Western Suffolk)

I want to get a restaurant gift certificate for someone & they live in the Bayshore area.
Any suggestions are appreciated.

Anne01 Posted: Dec 10, 2004 10:53 PM

Re: Can Anyone Recommend a Nice Restaurant (preferable Italian) on the South Shore? (pref. Western Suffolk)

In Babylon there is Gemelli's & Pete's Pasta.
In Islip there is Nuovolari.

Kel Posted: Dec 10, 2004 11:48 PM

Re: Can Anyone Recommend a Nice Restaurant (preferable Italian) on the South Shore? (pref. Western Suffolk)

None of the places are anything super fancy (Papa Joes would be the nicest) .. but the food is good .. especially Pizzaiola & Papa Joes!!

Papa Joes Pizza
450 Commack Rd
Deer Park
631-242-7160

Pizzaiola
1162 Deer Park Ave
North Babylon
631-242-6111

Victorio's II
20 Bay Shore Rd
Bay Shore
631-586-5552

Vinnie's Mulberry Street
192 Howells Rd
Bay Shore
631-665-2004

Shorty McBride Posted: Dec 11, 2004 02:18 PM

Re: Can Anyone Recommend a Nice Restaurant (preferable Italian) on the South Shore? (pref. Western Suffolk)

Posted by Kel

None of the places are anything super fancy (Papa Joes would be the nicest) .. but the food is good .. especially Pizzaiola & Papa Joes!!

mmmm i second papa joe's! Don't be fooled by the 'pizza' in the name- it is a restaurant too, and mmmm they make some great food!

matron Posted: Dec 11, 2004 03:05 PM

Re: Can Anyone Recommend a Nice Restaurant (preferable Italian) on the South Shore? (pref. Western Suffolk)

Mama Lombardi's is always good.

Also the Italian place diagonally across from Gemelli's in Babylon is good ... I forget the name right now.

AND -- Vinnie's Mulberry Street in Islip.