Deodorant Trial Results - Dove Clear vs. Secret Platinum Invisible

Now that we are into another round we have 5 categories over 2 days - total possible score of 50. I switched pits between today and yesterday for a fair trial.

The products are:

Dove Clear Solid - Original Scent vs.
Secret Platinum Invisible Solid - Mystic Rain


Dove Clear Solid:

APPLICATION: Went on dry an smooth, smelled nice at application - maybe took 1 minute total to dry (9/10)

WHITE MARKS: Although Clear is in the name it did leave some residue and small white mess, a disappointment in this area (6/10)

SCENT: Excellent, very, very nice. Did fade a bit during the day, but that is for another category (10/10)

SWEAT PROTECTION: Both days ended with a small amount of sweat and not total dryness, not super-strength (7/10)

ODOR PROTECTION: Althought the scent was excellent it did fade, and after 8-9 hours was totally gone allowing for some small amount of BO (6/10)

Total: 38/50


Secret Platinum Invisible:

APPLICATION: Smooth, very dry, again maybe less than a minute to fully dry and no residue at application (9/10)

WHITE RESIDUE: Simply put there wasn't any either day (10/10)

SCENT: Very nice, maybe slightly too strong at application, but certainly pleasing (9/10)

SWEAT PROTECTION: Awesome, was a strength against Lady Speed Stick, and it overpowered Dove in this area also (10/10)

ODOR PROTECTION: Either my co-worker was lying or the odor protection on the Secret side was well over 10 hours, impressive (9/10)

Total Score: 47/50


So, in a not too close contest Secret Platinum Invisible beats out Dove

Due to popular request I will not put Secret Platinum up against some type of Mitchum.

is this post serious?
thanks for the info

im going to try the secret!

THANKS for this! ive been using dove, but im going to try the secret now!

I feel so responsible for the dryness of others now - LOL!!!

---

Posted by FallBride2004

I feel so responsible for the dryness of others now - LOL!!!

---

LOL LOL LOL

We must all thank you sniffer!!!

I use Dove and Secret (switch off once in a while). Dove today, Secret last week.

I used Dove for years and then all of a sudden it failed on me (VERY embarrassing ) I have been using Secret Platinum and it has never failed.

This trial is hilarious!!

I have always used secret... I tried to change once and my armpits like freaked out and started breaking out...never again! My body's ph likes secret so that is good enough for me!!

I have been a Degree user for quite some time...It is great most of the day but not wonderful toward the end. Yuck! I bought Dove to try to get away from that and well that was misrubble...Today I went out...thanks to this thread...to buy Secret Invisible but soon ran into a dilemma! I was faced with both Secret Invisible Solid as well as Secret Platnum Invisible Solid (*& olay conditioners)! I couldn't remember which you had said was good. So faced with such a an obvious conundrum...I bought both. Has anyone used one over the other? Bad good?