did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
sagapo
Posted:
Member since
did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
my husband and i took the cake home from my moms freezer, and its been sitting in our fridge since november 25- time to toss?
haha
Eternalyyourz
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
it always sounds a little gross to me to eat a year old wedding cake!
BRod-Cheng
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
We did it. We kept if frozen. 2 days before our anniversary we took it out of the freezer to defrost and it actually tasted just fine. I only had a couple of slices, but DH finished the whole cake top.
Eternalyyourz
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
really? well thats good news! Because even if it didnt taste very well, we would have to eat it for good luck! :)
Goldi1021
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
I did. It was 'eh.' Certainly not spoiled though.
evnme
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
we ate ours. we thawed it out for 2 days. it was still pretty good!
Deedlebug126
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
I thawed it out and thought hard about it, but I just couldn't do it!
ChrisnAmy
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
We ate ours,....and Surprisingly it tasted very good!
beaviss80
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
we didn't, i couldn't bring myself to do it. instead we bought a mini carvel cake, had them write happy 1st anniversary and we had that...yum
waterspout4
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
You said it's been sitting in the fridge for nearly one month!?!?!?! Toss it!!!!! If it was still frozen, I say defrost it and try it.
EmberLynn
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
I didn't do the cake freezing thing. I might have if the cake had a different filling, (cannoli makes the cake wet when deforsted, which I can't stand.) We didn't even do a cake for an anniversary.
kissy27
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
We ate it on our actual anniversary & it was quite yummy. I was nervous at first, but I knew I had to do it bc of tradition. The cake was a little dry but otherwise it was very delish!
Eternalyyourz
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
Now that sounds yummy!
autumn
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
Posted by BRod-Cheng
We did it. We kept if frozen. 2 days before our anniversary we took it out of the freezer to defrost and it actually tasted just fine. I only had a couple of slices, but DH finished the whole cake top.
same here, I thought it was fine. We only ate a tiny piece. DH swears if he died it would be all my fault for making him eat the cake
kimnsteve
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
do you have to do something special when freezing it?
reenielady
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
We tried it the frosting tasted horrible
jtgarsik
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
we ate ours! it was actually really good! i was impressed - and ate it for 4days straight lol.
conigs25
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
Sure did!!! And it was SUPER YUMMY!!!!!
kns11
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
Posted by beaviss80
we didn't, i couldn't bring myself to do it. instead we bought a mini carvel cake, had them write happy 1st anniversary and we had that...yum
Love this idea! I certaintly would dive in with two forks in hand. Gotta love those cookie crumbs. DH and I ate ours once we came back from the honeymoon. I put it out as dessert for my BIL and SIL who had dinner with us before going back to Italy.
CKJ906
Posted:
Member since
Re: did anyone eat their wedding cake on their anniversary?
