dress with pics!

Hi Ladies...i said yes to the dress yesterday

I also went shopping with my sister (MOH) and she is torn between these two dresses. what do you think? #1 has a satin bottom and chiffon top, #2 is all chiffon. The satin one isnt the right size (its a little snug around her stomach). we dont have to order it for a few months (she hopes to lose some weight) but I am curious what you think bc so far me and my sis have one opinion and my mother & grandmother have another opinion. The prob with my MOH is she has HUGE boobs so she cant wear strapless. My MOH is going to set the tone as to what the other girls wear (material wise). what do you think???