E-Party CD Favors

*I'm posting this here too (also on '09 boards)- I need advice!

I'm trying to make the cd favors for our e-party but I need some help coming up with my song ideas and also trying to narrow it down to the best ones, here's a list of songs I jotted down. Let me know any other ideas or what I should narrow it down to - I want to get it down to 12-16 songs.

Sicilians - Amazed
Sicilians - Vivo Per Lei (with Reina)
Rockell & Collage - I'll Be Loving You
Rockell - In a Dream
Lisette Melendez - Together Forever
TKA - Louder Than Love
Barry White - My First, My Last, My Everything
Cascada or Savage Garden - Truly Madly Deeply
DHT - Someone
Edwin McCain - I'll Be
Goo Goo Dolls - Iris
Josh Groban - You Are Loved (Don't Give Up)
Josh Groban - Alla Luce Del Sole
Josh Groban - Un Amore Per Sempre
Josh Groban - In Her Eyes
(I need to narrow it down to two J. Groban songs - don't want too many!)
Sarah McLachlan - Ice Cream
Somewhere Over the Rainbow - Israel K. (the Hawaiin guy)
Michael Buble - Save the Last for Me
Andrea Bocelli - Because We Believe

Stand By You - (our engagement song! don't know if we're using the Pretenders or Carrie Underwood version though)

Sorry so long!! TIA!