Post New Topic

FILs Drama... Long

JimmysBride Posted:

FILs Drama... Long

So we went to see FILs for the holidays, we only stayed 2 days and we decided to ask our FG (FH's only niece) on this trip. That went fine, but we also wanted to ask FHs BIL (FG's Dad) to be a GM and we were undecided on asking his younger sis, the FG's mom, (we already asked his other sis) to be a BM.

We've been leaning toward NOT asking his younger sis -- let's call her 'Amy' -- to be a BM because FH doesn't get along with her well and she is a MAJOR drama queen. I'm not close with her at all, though I am close with his other sis -- let's call her 'Dee'.

FH takes it upon himself to bring up the issue of why Amy has not yet been asked to be a BM to his mom. Big mistake, I think, plus he didn't even discuss it with me first. Anyway, he tells her that we want her hubby-'Kevin', her daughter (the FG), and we would be honored if Amy did a reading but not be a BM because it would be too much of an expense for their one family. So, FMIL offers to pay for Amy's BM expenses. Luckily FH still tells we are undecided, because not 4 hrs later into our visit did he and Amy get into a little tiff.

Well, the spat was resolved pretty quickly but FH was still pretty pissed at her. Then some drama erupted over sleeping arrangements and we were booted from FMILs house to Dee's house thanks to Amy (an even longer story). Well, after all this I told FH that I REALLY did NOT want her to be a BM but I still really wanted Kevin and so did he.

So now the dilemma remains... Amy's daughter is the FG. We want Kevin as a GM, and we want Amy to do a reading, NOT as a BM. But now I'm worried that with Amy being such a friggin drama queen that if we ask Kevin and not her, she'll bug out and even pull her daughter out as an FG. Probably even at the last minute to be as dramatic as possible. Obviously, FH can't even be around her for more than 12 hrs without some kind of argument erupting, so she can't possibly be a BM. He thinks that maybe we should just ask neither of the parents. I feel terrible about the whole thing .... what do you girls think??

Sorry so long!

Jen_n_Dale Posted:

Re: FILs Drama... Long

Honestly, I would not ask one without the other. I would be hurt if my brother was getting married and then decided to ask my husband and daughter than not me..... No matter how much they might not like one another, I would be so offended. So I would just have the daughter and leave it at that.

DKA1026 Posted:

Re: FILs Drama... Long

I think you should ask both or neither. ut you can definitely still have the FG. Honestly, I think it is a little weird to have a married person paired off with someone else in a BP. Most likely, i would keep both of them out and just have their daughter as FG.

B2BMay04 Posted:

Re: FILs Drama... Long

Since you know Amy is likely to cause a problem I would not ask her to be in the wedding. I would not ask her hubby either because that would cause major drama. Ask the FG and maybe ask Kevin to do a reading since you really want to include him. If you HAVE to give her something to do let her bring up the gifts :)

My rule is this... if there is a chance it will cause stress and I can avoid it .... then I do. Your happiness is what matters and you do not need anyone causing problems.
Tammy5-03 Posted:

Re: FILs Drama... Long

I agree, just ask the FG. She'll be more offended if you ask her husband to be in it but not her. At least I would be. Do you have to ask the other sister? I know you like her but it would go over better if you only had your friends and family as BMs and no one from his side. Just a thought.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.