Fun Wedding Invitation

I am thinking I want the wording on our invitations to be casual and fun. Dis anyone else go with the non-traditional invitation?
FH and I were high school sweethearts, he was my first love, first boyfriend and after 9 years we broke up and now 15 years (and one marriage for me)later we finally got it right.
I want the invitation to reflect this. I was thinking maybe a First Love quote on it, or a line from our first dance song which is After All by Cher and Peter Cetera. This is the line I was thinking of using:
'We've tried it on our own, but deep inside we've known
We'd be back to set things straight'

Any help or suggestions (and opinions) is greatly appreciated.

The more personal the better. I found two quotes that I thought could help ' I've fallen in love many times... always with you.' -Author Unknown

The second 'The minute I heard my first love story I started looking for you, not knowing how blind that was. Lovers don't finally meet somewhere. They're in each other all along.' -Rumni

Good luck!!!