Post New Topic

Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

bride2be2012 Posted:

Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

Ahhh! I really, really want a cardbox, but my mom is SO insistent on not having a cardbox. Apparently 'jews don't have that.' I think it's totally ridic but there is def no way I am getting around her, my wedding or not.

So, for those of you not doing a cardbox, are you doing anything else instead or just the old hand off to the parents?
CaughtMyFish Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

Dont you just love the 'jews dont xxxx' comments?!

I am a Jew, and borrowing a birdcage from a friend. I may put some ribbon on it, but that's about all she wrote. lol

I dont DIY, so that's of course an issue.
EmilyandPeter Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

I'm borrowing the bird cage from my cousins wedding... and I'm not jewish. I like the bird cage look.

bride2be2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by CaughtMyFish

Dont you just love the 'jews dont xxxx' comments?!

I am a Jew, and borrowing a birdcage from a friend. I may put some ribbon on it, but that's about all she wrote. lol

I dont DIY, so that's of course an issue.



Ahh I can't stand the 'jews don't xxx' comments anymore! Oh and I should've mentioned that bird cages are out as well, since those are also apparently a no go
CaughtMyFish Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

well there are wedding envelope holders that are like large flat purses. They are fabric and sometimes are quilted, or patterned. I personally am not a fan bc someone can just lift it and walk off, but you can talk to your Mom about this as an option.

AlexandMike2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

why don't you do the silk bag like the old school iIalians do...Goodfellas style....just ask everyone to line up and hand you their envelopes My mom found the old one they used for their wedding and asked me if i wanted it lol

No but seriously I was just at a Jewish wedding and they had a card box
Jill52787 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

I went to a Jewish wedding last year and I remember saying to FH how the cardbox was so nice. This is something I;d go bridezilla on, if you really want it, I'd get one and hide it until that day LOL

bride2be2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by AlexandMike2012

why don't you do the silk bag like the old school iIalians do...Goodfellas style....just ask everyone to line up and hand you their envelopes My mom found the old one they used for their wedding and asked me if i wanted it lol

No but seriously I was just at a Jewish wedding and they had a card box



I KNOW that jewish people have them these days, but it is just sooo not worth the stress of arguing with my mom

thanks date twinnie!!
AlexandMike2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

what if you get one and try and make believe it's a decoration??? lol worth a shot!

CaughtMyFish Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

FWIW, the FMIL did ask me if I was doing a cardbox, and I said I had a birdcage coming on loan. We are all Jewish too, so she wasnt against the idea when she asked.

Maybe your Mom needs to back off on this one! lol
bride2be2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by CaughtMyFish

FWIW, the FMIL did ask me if I was doing a cardbox, and I said I had a birdcage coming on loan. We are all Jewish too, so she wasnt against the idea when she asked.

Maybe your Mom needs to back off on this one! lol



lol trust me - I have tried!!!!!!!! Even my FSIL (who isn't jewish) isn't having one when her and my brother get married in August b/c my mom is so against it. I have tried and tried, but I don' think there is any winning this battle!
Bride in 2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

Get one that looks like a wedding cake - she'll never know the difference. Then, have them roll your real cake out when it's time to cut it. Can you imagine the look on her face then?
Future Mrs Snuggle Bunny Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

I am doing the silk bag. I think the card boxes are a waste of money to purchase. Borrow one or maybe rent?

soon2beMrsHenry92912 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by Bride in 2012

Get one that looks like a wedding cake - she'll never know the difference. Then, have them roll your real cake out when it's time to cut it. Can you imagine the look on her face then?



This!!!
bride2be2012 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??

omg that is the cutest thing ever!!! I am SOOOO going to fight for that photo frame box!!!

bella_bride Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by AlexandMike2012

why don't you do the silk bag like the old school iIalians do...Goodfellas style....just ask everyone to line up and hand you their envelopes My mom found the old one they used for their wedding and asked me if i wanted it lol

No but seriously I was just at a Jewish wedding and they had a card box




roblisa09 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by christinajimmy06

What about something like this?

It's just a bunch of photographs of you and FH, nothing more.... LOL



Love this idea!!!!
eck739 Posted:

Re: Girls NOT DOING Cardboxes??


Posted by Jill52787

I went to a Jewish wedding last year and I remember saying to FH how the cardbox was so nice. This is something I;d go bridezilla on, if you really want it, I'd get one and hide it until that day LOL



SAME...its your wedding...get it if you want it.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.