Post New Topic

have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

Original post by MuchInLuvMichi

obviously things like lying, cheating, abuse are deal breakers in a relationship...what r some dumb deal breakers that u may have had??

i dated a guy who was irish and for some crazy reason he reminded me of a leprachan..i dont even know y, he was soo nice yet i couldnt get it out of my head..then he shows me his clover tattoo on his leg and it was over!!

my friend broke up witha guy cause he wouldnt share his $13.00 bottle of shampooo!!!
The Original 2nd-time-around Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

I broke up with a (really cute!) guy becuase he did this 'thing' with his hand when he talked. It annoyed the heck out of me

HearzBellz Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by kpny622

I broke up with a guy because at the end of every sentence, he'd add, 'eh?' He was Canadian and ever since then, when I meet a Canadian, turns out they do the same exact thing! It drives me nuts!



I used to make fun of a friend of mine for saying 'abooot'...uh that accent kills me
Jan05Bride Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by The Original 2nd-time-around

I broke up with a (really cute!) guy becuase he did this 'thing' with his hand when he talked. It annoyed the heck out of me



I hate skeeving hands ... hard to explain I know, but you can tell alot about a person by their gestures.

HearzBellz Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by CherylBooch

Ok you're going to think I'm lying about this, but my DH was there!! (we were just friends then)

I broke up with someone because he told me that he wanted to give up 'All sexual contact for Lent'

I was like 'Are you seriouly kidding me?'



oh my
februarybride Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

These are so funny
nov04LIbride Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

Ummm can't stand back hair! Broke up with a guy or two as soon as I saw them shirtless!
Donna Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

I was probably about 17 and this guy I was dating gave me his necklace to wear because I was so special.
Well when I closely looked it (it was that rectangle with the playboy bunny symbol in the corner and his name imprinted diagonally)
the back was engraved Dear X, All my love, Mary.
He still didn't see the big deal about it. Hence just one more reason for the breakup
boosh78201 Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

I once broke up with a guy because I didnt like the way he talked. Oh and he would always stuff his hand down his pants.

don424 Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by boosh78201

I once broke up with a guy because I didnt like the way he talked. Oh and he would always stuff his hand down his pants.



yep, but eventually she came back to me and now we're married

D&J Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

I broke up with someone because of...

1. Chest hair - blech.. I like a chest to be smooooooth

2. Way to much pubie hair for my liking.

3. Breathing like a donkey

4. Smoking too much - Cigs & Weed

5. Being to needy

6. Calling me constantly




These are different guys, different situations.. I guess there are reasons why it took me 31 years to get married..
gertyrae Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

I broke up with one guy cuz he smelled bad, another cuz he 'couldn't find his money' on a lunch date (our third), and another cuz he kept telling me he was falling in love with me(this after dating for a week or so)...
The second guy was sooo p.o.'d he kept calling and fighting with me about it, made me glad I broke it off right away!
Kriss2c Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by D&J

I broke up with someone because of...

1. Chest hair - blech.. I like a chest to be smooooooth

2. Way to much pubie hair for my liking.

3. Breathing like a donkey

4. Smoking too much - Cigs & Weed

5. Being to needy

6. Calling me constantly


These are different guys, different situations.. I guess there are reasons why it took me 31 years to get married..



Funny, I broke up with a guy who did all of the last 4. I'm getting married just shy of my 30th... see, you could have saved a year if you just dated this same jerk.
nov04LIbride Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by embee

I broke up with a guy because he said 'wooder' rather than 'water' it drove me crazy.


I do this! I grew up in New Jersey--I think it is a Jersey thing.
MrsTC Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by tracyg

i broke up witha sloppy kisser too.... thats the worst!



ugh that's the worst! i have had that experience too....everything else was fine..but that's the dealbreaker LOL!
MrsTC Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by nov04LIbride


Posted by embee

I broke up with a guy because he said 'wooder' rather than 'water' it drove me crazy.


I do this! I grew up in New Jersey--I think it is a Jersey thing.



ok so i am a jersey transplant but one other word i noticed that people from jersey say is 'begel' instead of bagel. Oh, and 'laig' instead of leg. I think some LIers do this too LOL!
RedHead Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??


Posted by tracyg

i broke up witha sloppy kisser too.... thats the worst!

DITTO!
BlondeJD Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

This will sound really bad, but I'll be honest. In high school I broke up with this kid for not fitting in with my group of friends--he was a little too goth and I was a lot preppy. I thought my friends would be like WT*F, so we sort of dated in secret for a month or two (only he didn't know it was a secret).

What makes it worse is that I broke up with him by not calling him or returning his calls--this was before I became confrontational. I was a bit shallow in high school, huh?
Xelindrya Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

Hrmmm..

I broke up with a guy because he didnt call me in a week. We'd been pretty hot and heavy and I was suspicious so I figured, no call, no gal pal for him.

I didnt leave a message saying it was over, I just walked away. Started seeing a guy from NYC (haha that's why I moved here)

The weekend before I left Texas my Austin buddies threw me a party and the 'guy' showed up. Our buddies didnt know we were an item, we kept our relationship private.

Well guess what?

He had a major motorcycle accident had his knee was the size of a basketball after reconstructive surgery. His father was a doctor and for the previous month he'd been home with them.

I broke up because he didnt call, but he couldnt!!!! *shrug* Oh well. Came to NY, dumped the guy I moved here for and met Jim.

All's well that ends well!
butterfly20 Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

yes, many times for a stupid little reason....
maybe i didnt care for their clothing, even though if i asked they would wear whatever i like....
or if they were too skinny...
or had a weird laugh........
there were a bunch of different reasons....

..... to my defense this was all while i was still in h.s. and im not the same way anymore...
prncssrachel Posted:

Re: have u ever broken up with someone for a dumb reason??

I broke up with a guy before I was dating JT because we were only together for about a month when my girlfriend and I were looking to rent a house together, and he just ASSUMED he'd be moving into the house with us I told him we couldn't afford a three bedroom

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.