Honeymoon help Please....Antigua or Punta Cana

Hi ladies,
FH and I are trying to decide where to go on our October honeymoon...
At first we wanted to go to antigua, (either Sandals or galley bay) then we came across a great deal at the Majestic Colonial in Punta Cana, Dominican Repulic.

We both haven't been to either, and as much as I want to save money, I don't want to just book the cheaper trip (it is our hm).

Just wondering if any one has any suggestions on either place?? We def want all inclusive, casinos, good food/drinks, and some activities...

TIA!!!

I've been to DR three times. Twice to Puerto Plata and once to Punta Cana. I Punta Cana. It is gorgeous. FH and I stayed at the Melia Caribe Tropical. We had a great time. The beaches are incredible, the pool is amazing, and the resort is huge. We didn't go off the resort too much. The only time was when we went to the waterpark to swim with the dolphins.