I know i have asked but i still need help

Can someone just tell me where to go on our honeymoon. I am driving myself crazy looking all over. Jamaica? St. THomas? Bahamas?
Any input will be helpfull.

We're going on a western caribbean cruise (Mexico, Grand Cayman & Jamaica).

We had no idea where to go and its not so expensive either.

Sounds like you're looking in the Carribean. I've been to a bunch of islands, some I loved, some not so much.

St. Thomas felt like I was in Florida. It was totally Americanized, and lacked all of the culture of the other islands.

The Bahamas were fun, but you have to be careful where you stay since some parts aren't so nice. If you go to Paradise Island you'll have no problem, it's beautiful.

I loved, St. Martin, Barbados, and even though some people don't consider it carribean, Cozumel. I had friends that went to Cozumel for their honeymoon b/c I loved it there so much. They had an amazing time.

Hope this helps some...

ETA: It also depends what you are looking for: night life, good snorkling/scuba diving, nice beaches, culture/history...also you need to consider if you want to leave the resort to do things/explore, or go to an all inclusive where you just stay on the property.

I probably just confused you more...sorry.