Post New Topic

Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

PeteysBride Posted:

Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

This is going to sound terrible but....

I was considering not giving my 3 bridesmaids anything as a gift. And before the yells go up, let me explain why.

1. I have never heard about this tradition before. Neither had my mother or her two sisters (the girls mothers.) The girls don't know about it. In my family its just 'expected' cousins/brothers/sisters will be in the bridal party. When i gave them the BM cards, they all were like what's this? Not that they were suprised I asked, but surprised that I had made it formal.

2. The girls are all WAY younger than me-I do not know them personally at all and they all ahve VASTLY different tastes.

As horrid as it is to say this, I am ostracized from the rest of the family for being 'too white' because I wear clothes from Ann Taylor and the Gap and prefer pearls to bracelet size hoop earrings and name plates as wide as my four fingers. They don't include me in things when they come here for vacation though they do go out with my cousins who lives here and my brother. Aside from loving them because they are my family, I do not have a relationship at all with these women-no letters, no phone calls, no pictures so it makes choosing a gift harder and they wouldnt appreciate a pretty locket or pearl bracelt.

3. They didnt pay for ANYTHING. MY mother ordered and paid for their dresses-she will split the bill with one aunt (the mother of the girl that lives here, not in PR) because my other aunt doesnt work so she doesnt have the money. They will pay for their hair, makeup, shoes, etc. The girls are paying NOTHING out of pocket so it hasnt been an inconvenience for them at all.

4. The day that we were supposed to meet to measure them and order their dresses, they were an hour late.... My aunt is always late everywhere but these are grown up girls-two of them drive and the thirdcan go with them. They knew we had to get up at 8am and yet went to bed at 3am that day for no reason, and when I left at 10 to 10am that morning for the store, they were still in bed.

Sounds like whining and mayeb it is, but having them in the bridal party was more of a 'have to' than a 'want to.' Thats why i am thinking we just won't give them anything except hug and kisses because they arent helping me with the wedding planning at all-actually been cold towards me.

My MOH on the other hand has been wonderful. I just put her in after kicking the last diva girl out (some people may remember that post) and she is just wonderful-best friend I have. (originally didnt put her in because we are getting amrried two weeks apart and wanted to save one another money but now we said we wont give presents, just be in each others wedding) So I want to do soemthign really special for her. She acyually surprised me by buying the headpiece I wanted behind my back. LOL had to tell me because I planned to order it this week and told her.

Anyway, enough rambling. Now that you ahve the backstory, do you think I can get away with not giving the BM's anything? We didnt even know about the gift tradition....
GinaZ Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

Usually I would say no, that is not okay- but in your instance, you dont have to get them a gift. BUT, are you doing anything like a bridesmaids brunch or something like that? In which case you should invite them since they are in the wedding. And maybe the day of the wedding give them a card thanking them for their participation- even if it was minimal. While you dont have to give a gift, you still want to be the bigger person.

HTH
PeteysBride Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

They don't live here so they wont be able to attend any of the showers, etc. I would give them a card of course but as far as a gift, the only thing they would do is be here the day of.

Kara and Todd Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

In this instance, I consider their dresses, hair, make-up, etc. their gift. I don't think any other gift is necessary. If they were paying for that themselves, though, I would say you should give a gift. Since they're not, I think paying for that stuff is MORE than generous!

ETA - A TY card would be a nice touch, of course!
july06bride Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

in this case I dont think another gift is necessary since I would consider the dress and everything else a gift...

kat74 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to give my BMs a gift? I ask because....

I agree with the other girls-- since they are not paying for anything then you don't HAVE to buy them anything.

But if you want them to all wear a similar necklace or earrings to ensure they don't have flashy jewelry on -- like you mentioned in your post-- then maybe you could present an inexpensive jewelry set to them gift wrapped as their gift.

This way you look generous and you ensure good taste for your pictures!!!!
natseven Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....


Posted by kat74

I agree with the other girls-- since they are not paying for anything then you don't HAVE to buy them anything.

But if you want them to all wear a similar necklace or earrings to ensure they don't have flashy jewelry on -- like you mentioned in your post-- then maybe you could present an inexpensive jewelry set to them gift wrapped as their gift.

This way you look generous and you ensure good taste for your pictures!!!!



I agree. no gift is necessary but if you want matching jewelry for the girls...that's the only thing I would spend money on them for.
drpepper318 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

In your situation, I think it's not necessary at all to get them anything.

libby2595 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

here is another vote in the same sentiment as the other posters. i would not feel obligated to buy them anything more... BESIDES inexpensive jewelry, to ensure that they all look more uniform.

PeteysBride Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

Thanks guys. I appreciate the feedback. Im nto cheap! Really lol but I am a teacher-well student teacher and we make ZIP until we are hired by board of ed. So have to be thrifty where I can and honestly they arent even that excited. Its just something to do. Kind of disaapointing but family are the ties that bind and gag.

Thanks!
libby2595 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

i re-read your question as i was looking around... and i had a thought i wanted to share with you.

obviously, your family had different traditions (being that you are latina... i'm assuming this because you mentioned pr) than those you might read about on these threads.

i just wanted you to remember, that people from different cultures, countries, and even different parts of the same country do things (especially weddings) differently.

what it a custom by latinos, might be considered 'wrong' by another ethnicity and vice versa.

i hope i'm making sense.

Audreygirl Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

Get them a nice Thank You card.

PeteysBride Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

Ok so I decided to make them custom thank you cards because Im creative like that with handwritten thank you's and these little lip glosses, hand lotions and breath mints that I bought from bath and body works (like 5 bucks per girl) to keep their wedding beauty together.

BTW Libby mentioned this place that does customized cosmetic bags and they are really inexpensive and it is a FABULOUS idea. I think I am going to make one for my MOH and then add stuff inside of it. I LOVE the idea because we all use makeup bags at some point and she is always lugging hers around. (dont know if she would wear jewlery again because she has her own style)

So special thanks to libby and thanks to everyone else who helped me out. Love u all!
pameladhd Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

Hon:

Remeber this: It is your wedding and you should do whatever you are comfortable with. Period. It seems like you feel a certain way so trust your instincts.

Best of Luck!
shelby34 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

Normally I would say you have to give them a gift, but if they are getting everything paid for them, then that is their gift. Maybe you could give them a card and a box of nice chocolate or something little.

Meaghan729 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

I would buy them all inexpensive necklaces or other piece of jewelery to wear on the wedding day.

happygirl07 Posted:

Re: Is it tacky not to gve my BMs a gift? I ask because....

I agree with the majority of the posters to not get them anything. You're giving them a TY card and the cosmetic bags. That's good enough.

Oh, and I totally understand where you're coming from in terms of traditions and your likes and dislikes.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.