JUDGE/JOP - SUFFOLK - PLEASE HELP

FH and I are getting married at the Miller Place Inn in Miller Place on a Sunday afternoon.
Can anyone suggest someone to marry us that wont cost $500?
We dont want a religious or spiritual wedding. Just a pretty, 'I do', 'I do' you may now kiss the bride ceremony.

The Miller Place inn gave me a judge they recommend but Im not SO sure he's the one I want by speaking to him on the phone.