Looking for an INDOOR site for wedding ceremony only, non religious- March 10th 2012

Ok so I found a great private location for my reception, but it does not have a room I can have my ceremony in and I cannot have the ceremony in the same room.

I am looking for something relatively cheap since I was just planning on going to town hall in like, my sweatpants that morning (haha) but I'm trying to appease both my own mother and my mother-in-law-to-be by looking for a ceremony location. Any [cheap] location help would be appreciated! Looking for something for Saturday, March 10, 2012, any where from 2-5pm. My reception will be in Middle Island (suffolk county) but as long as I have enough travel time I don't have a preference for a location. Quick ceremony and I even have an officiant. No churches, chapels, synogogues please, I am not religious and don't want that involved in the ceremony at all.

I called three places [catering halls since I cannot find ANYTHING] and they tried to sell me on the reception in a pushy way so I was turned off by them.

Would you consider a church that is only around for historic reasons? There is a church building in Sayville on the corner of Montaulk Hwy and Broadway Ave. Its small and only seats maybe 60 people. Its owned by the town of Islip and I believe it was rather inexpensive to get married there. Its non-denominational so there is no clergy and so forth involved. Its never used for anything other than wedding from what I understand. I'll see if I can find the link online to it.


ETA: The 'church' itself is on the bottom of the page but as you can see there are also places for pictures.

Here is the link

I really don't want to be inside any place of worship, even if it's not used for that anymore. I saw a few that were historical, but I want to avoid them since it actually makes me angry to even step foot in one (probably NOT the mood I'm going for on my 'big day' hahaha)

I have even considered theatres although I don't know of any that would allow it.

I'm inviting 90 people, but not sure who'd actually come to the ceremony if it's at a different site. I'd consider a house, but I'd still have to rent chairs and decorate so the costs keep adding up (80 chairs cost around $300-500)- you're right about using the word 'wedding' !!! Potential vendors' eyes light up like I'm an ATM....