Post New Topic

My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

PrincessRose Posted:

My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

This is my review of Jersey Girl, reposted from my Weblog. Be forewarned, however, Kevin Smith, the writer/director, is my FAVORITE filmmaker, so I'm biased. But FH loved it too. If anyone needs to see it, and has no one to go with, let me know because I'm there.

JERSEY GIRL. GOOD MOVIE. LOVE KEVIN. LOTS. I'm so impressed with this movie. Kevin's really growing as a filmmaker and writer, but all the usual witty, quotable dialogue is still there. Adam and I kept saying 'Take her to see the cats' (one of Carlin's lines) all night after we left. Only one problem, really. Now that he's making movies with wider appeal (I'm even suggesting this movie to my parents), the movie theater was FULL OF CHILDREN last night. I'm talking 16 year olds. LOUD, OBNOXIOUS 16 year olds, who can't stop talking during a movie if their life depends on it. I even saw some kids who couldn't have even been in double digits there. What's that all about? HELLO?! Don't take your kids to see this movie, it's not a kid movie! But maybe after they all saw the Passion, this is nothing. Then again, Affleck said 'F***' and I heard this loud Gasp. ::shakes head:: Oh well, onto actual details of the movie, which probably contains a few spoilers, but nothing you haven't already heard/read about.

J-Lo is in the movie for a total of 10 minutes, which is both good and bad. The funny thing is that as much as I knew about the movie, and as much as I've been following this movie since it was first being written, it only really JUST hit me that J-Lo was in the movie. Like, I knew, but it was very strange to see her. I got over it quick though. Adam didn't like her. I thought she did a good job. But she's gone as quickly as she's there. I feel bad for Kevin though - all the bad press he got for casting her in the first place, all the money he had to pay her for those ten minutes. Whatever, she was always supposed to die, but it would've been better if they'd been able to go with the original marketing plan. We'd all be SHOCKED about her dying, you know?

Affleck. Those who have known me for a long time know that I've never been a huge Affleck fan - I kinda put up with him to see Kevin's movies. However, this is the most convincing performance I've ever seen from him. Granted, that's not saying much, but it's an improvement. I love him most of all in the school play scene - that's really where he shines, IMO.

Liv Tyler - Holy cr@p. Man, she's just amazing. I liked her before, I love her now. Please, dear Lord, let me someday be as talented as Liv Tyler, or at least have an opportunity to display that talent. DEAD ON Casting choice here. She is also surprisingly good in the School Play scene, that just blew me away. And her ability with Subtext is also A++++++++. There are moments when she's saying one thing, and thinking/feeling another, but you REALLY have to look at her to get it, because she's just playing it SO cool.

George Carlin - Better than I've ever seen him. I had no idea he would be this good in this kind of role, as funny as he is in stand-up and books. I'm glad that Kevin wrote it for him and he could take it. Incidentally, Kevin wrote the Jason Biggs (good job from him, btw) role for Jay Mewes, originally, but because of all his drug problems, he couldn't take the role. A bunch of other familiar faces are there, however. Jen, Mrs. Kevin, has a small role, as well as the bartender from Dogma, Cohee Lundin from Chasing Amy, and I'm pretty sure I saw Rick Derris too. Oh, and I'm certain that I saw Ming in a crowd shot. OH - Harley Quinn, the ORIGINAL Jersey Girl , also has a cameo, as if Kevin will ever make another movie without putting his kid on the screen. She's so cute!

OK, finally (I know I'm long winded, but whatever), the Kid/title role. Raquel Castro is Mini-Lo. In an almost disturbing way. What I love about that is that she's playing a little girl who is amazingly like the Mother she never knew. She's got all the mannerisms down, and she doesn't seem eerily adult, like Dakota Fanning does. Nothing's forced, it's all very natural coming from her. And her ability to handle Sondheim patter songs also impressed me. I really hope this is not her only foray into showbiz, because she's got a lot of potential.

Ok, so can you tell I LOVED the movie? I did. Go see it, don't talk during the movie, turn your cell phone off, and leave your children at home.
LisaW Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

DH and I are big Kevin Smith fans and are soooooooooooooooo looking forward to seeing this!!

Thanks for the review!!!

sarahthegreat Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

OOk, so I may not be th ebiggest fan of Kevin Smith, and Ben Affleck is starting to get on my nerves, but I do want to see JErsey Girl, my FH is s HUGE Kevin SMith fan, owns just about every movie on DVD and the short lived animated Clerks season, so he already said numerous times that he wants to see this movie. So, PrincesRose, since you enjoyed it, I guess we will go and see it. I hear it only got 1 star. Any comments on that??

PrincessRose Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

1 Star?

I've read quite a few 3 star reviews.

Yeah, the movie's mushy. It's got some cliches in it, but Cliches exist simply because they WORK.

Go see the movie.

I don't know what your FH would say about it, seeing as he seems to be as hard core a fan as I am, and I can see where someone might be disappointed. BUT, go see it.
sarahthegreat Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!


Posted by PrincessRose

1 Star?

I've read quite a few 3 star reviews.

Yeah, the movie's mushy. It's got some cliches in it, but Cliches exist simply because they WORK.

Go see the movie.

I don't know what your FH would say about it, seeing as he seems to be as hard core a fan as I am, and I can see where someone might be disappointed. BUT, go see it.



I thought it only got 1, but I could be wrong. It wouldn't be the first time. I've also heard that this is not a typical KS movie. But, we will go see it and hopefuuly we will both enjoy it. Thanks for the review and I agree with you 10000% on the kids in the theather thing, we went to see The Passion and there were 2 15 year olds nect to us who would not shut up, some movies i know people talk in, and its annoying, but to me, during this movie, it was particulary disturbing.
PrincessRose Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

You could be right about the 1 star - not every reviewer is going to give it the same number of stars. And I've heard that there have been some pretty harsh reviews. It's ENTIRELY possible.

Just don't listen to the critics because they're usually wrong anyway.
janwinterbridejoy Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

dh is a huge fan of kevin smith and so is my brother but both were hedging on the odea of going to see it because they thought it was to chick flick related lol. but ill tell them its a must lol. Thanks for the review rachel

IrishTracy Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

I love Kevin Smith movies!! I even liked Mallrats!! (Which Kevin Smith thinks was pure crap)
I would like to see the movie.
pschica Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

glad to hear it - we are going 2night to see it! yey!

sweetadeline Posted:

Re: My Review of Jersey Girl! VERY long!

Thanks for the detailed review!

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.