Need Help with BM DOJ!!

Bear with me here....

So I love these earrings from lia sophia: (sorry I can't post the image)

Bella Donna Earrings

But it doesn't really have a necklace to match. The closest thing that is also very nice is this one. ('necklace 1')

However, after a little research, I found this necklace online, which is similar, but not exactly the same.

Necklace 2


Which one works better? (the girls are in strapless dresses)

I actually have the first necklace. My BFF gave it to us as BP gifts for her wedding

But I think the second necklace goes much better.

I have that Lia Sophia Bel Aire necklace...& it broke within a month

I think the 2nd one goes better with the earrings