I've posted this a few times - I got these prices last April for a Saturday night in September/October/November.
I almost got married in NJ, but for several reasons that didn't work out. The halls are in NJ and Westchester. These prices include tax and tip.
Indian Trail Club - $130-$150 (my friend got married here and it was great. Good food, gorgeous place)
Stoney Hill Inn - $150 - very nice, great food - only negative was that it's right off of Route 80, but you can barely tell from the Inn
The Olde Mill Inn - $170 - GORGEOUS. We actually wanted to have it there, but the price was more than we wanted to spend and it was a little further than we wanted family to have to drive
Twin Brooks CC - $80 - $130
The Brownstone - $113 - $145
Basking Ridge CC - $113 - $139
Colonia CC - $75 - $125
Lake Mohawk CC - $186
Old Orchard Manor - $38 - $130
Brooklake CC - $124
Sea Oaks CC - $92 - $136
Knoll CC - $85 - $140
Pennsauken CC - $72
Atrium Country Club - $80 - 150
Buena Vista Country Club - $55
Crystal Point Yacht Club - $90 - $108
The Newark Club - $85 - $155
Valley Regency - $202
Valleybrook Country Club - $68 - $85
Westmount Country Club - $85
Nanina's In the Park - $202
Crystal Springs Country Club - $186 - 214
Ramsey Golf & Country Club - $101 - 189
The Clubhouse at Patriot Hills - $120 - $132
The Mill at Spring Lake Heights - $129 - $150
Eagle Ridge Golf Club - $145 - $189
ETA - here's 2 links to other NJ threads.
NJ - 1 NJ - 2