NWR: What show should I go to?

I've seen wicked from your list, but not the other two you mentioned.
I have seen many other great broadway plays but since you didn't mention them, i will keep my opinion to the ones you did
Wicked, is without a doubt, unlike anything else i have ever seen in my life. the story line, the scenery the music - its all out of this world incredible. the passion of the play gets to you and was phenomenal.
I would highly recommend it.

ive seen all three and i would say mama mia is last on the 'must see list'

I personally liked jersey boys best...its fun when you know the songs