OFFICIAL Amercian Idol thread.... LOVE SONG week

This Tivo gal watched tonight too I was glad Kelli went home. She was REALLY bad for 2 weeks and I never thought she was the same quality as the other finalists.

It was Kellie's time... Paula actually was right for once, when she said there hasn't been any 'growth' with Kellie, she was good, but in this type of competition, you need to consistantly get better every week.

Still don't know what it is about Elliot that irks me....

---

Posted by Chelle

Just watched it on Tivo and THANK GOD Pickler went home.

YEAH for Chirs and Katherine!!

---

I was so happy Chris and Katherine were top two - I bet Elliott was #3 (as Taylor wasn't as good as normal).

I hope Paris is out next week.

I think she can sing, but she just doesn't have 'Amercian Idol' written on her face. She needs to be singing in some smokey jazz clubs where her voice is the strongest.

Elliot CONTINUES to surprise me each week. I think he's awesome.

I said it before, but Taylor really bored me this week. He wasn't himself and it showed. Although I really do like him.

Katherine... she's one to compete with!

Chris - Well, we ALL know how I feel about him I think he's been the most consistent throughout this whole competition. There has been NO song he hasn't rocked.

IMO, he should go all the way. But even if America doesn't vote for him to win, we'll see him somwhere big ladies, don't you worry about that!!