Post New Topic

PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!

Original post by holly231

omg...I cannot believe the redhead beat out the other guy......

and I LOOOOOOOOOOVE the girl...shes so cute!! So is her family!
Stacey1403 Posted:

Re: PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!

I also thought that the guy that never made it through that answered Simon's question about what he would do with all the money he would make in a manner that Simon didn't like.



Holy run on sentence My SM would not be pleased(she's an english teacher )
violet Posted:

Re: PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!

Wild Card wouldn't bring back scooter girl or that other guy because they were never picked to go on in these competitions that they're doing now. They're only picking out people who didn't make it on the last 3 shows.

Stacey1403 Posted:

Re: PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!


Posted by violet

Wild Card wouldn't bring back scooter girl or that other guy because they were never picked to go on in these competitions that they're doing now. They're only picking out people who didn't make it on the last 3 shows.



Untrue. Simon brought back Carmen and she never made it through
violet Posted:

Re: PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!

I thought I had seen Carmen on one of those competitions, the ones they're doing now.

Stacey1403 Posted:

Re: PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!

She was only on the Wild Card show

Simon felt bad he never put her through
violet Posted:

Re: PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DID NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL!

Well then she was just really lucky. I thought they determined it by whoever made it to 3rd-5th place on each show.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.