Post New Topic

Recommend Seafood Restaurants

GT143EA Posted:

Recommend Seafood Restaurants

We are going out to dinner for my moms bday tomorrow and she wants seafood. Can you recommend a good seafood restaurant in Suffolk County. TIA!!
allegracristina Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

I know you asked for Suffolk but I can't help with that, so I'll help where I can. My favorite is Riverbay in Albertson!

Brat23 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

Sea Haven in Lindenhurst on Montauk Hgwy I heard is good also Pier 44 in Babylon is great too!

geegee827 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

I absolutely love Legal Seafood in Walt Whitman mall.

Brat23 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

Also Captain Bills my FMIL works there

alli3131 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

what about Southside in Lindenhurst. I hate seafood but FH loves it there.

christophersgirl Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants


Posted by geegee827

I absolutely love Legal Seafood in Walt Whitman mall.




i love this place too haha
MrsDtoBe09 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

All my favorite seafood places are on City Island, so I'm no help!

GT143EA Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants


Posted by Brat23

Also Captain Bills my FMIL works there



Do you know if they have a dress code?
Soon_to_be_Stanek Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants


Posted by allegracristina

I know you asked for Suffolk but I can't help with that, so I'll help where I can. My favorite is Riverbay in Albertson!



thats the restaurant we went to when my FH first met my whole family!!!
smrsun Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants


Posted by christophersgirl


Posted by geegee827

I absolutely love Legal Seafood in Walt Whitman mall.




i love this place too haha



Ditto! Their crabcakes are so yummy!
Summertimegal424 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

Captain Bills

Almostawife Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

how about H2O

coldasice217 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

I'm really no help cuz I don't eat much seafood, but I DO like Red Lobster lol. You can't really beat the cheesy biscuits.

LeeAnne Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

H2O in smithtown
harbor crab company in patchogue
oar house in patchogue (MY FAV!)
michelle1024 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

Captain Bills def!! Also, the snapper inn in oakdale is good.

GT143EA Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

Thanks for all your recommendations girls! We decided to go to Captain Bills. So we have a reservation for tomorrow night at 6:30.

ANT-N-BON-09 Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

ur gonna like it, goood food!

christophersgirl Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

ive been to a wedding there and i only have good memories of the food from that place, it's gonna be real tasty
MLAngelo Posted:

Re: Recommend Seafood Restaurants

There all listed here... but Captain Bills, Snapper Inn and H20 are the best seafood places around in my opinion.

Oh and Fat Fish, but thats really better in the summer, the indoors is small.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.