LIWeddings.com
Post New Topic

Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

CandB4604 Posted:

Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Hey there! Our reception hall hired Create-A-Cake or Rolling Pin to make our wedding cake. So, of the two, does anyone have a preference?

TIA!
squeekietoy Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Rolling Pin. Personally, I hate Create a Cake. Yuck.

CandB4604 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Wow! I have never been to Create-A-Cake, but I keep hearing the same things. I'm so glad I asked! And then - do you particularly like Rolling Pin?

squeekietoy Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Answered you on the 09 board. I've never had cake from Rolling Pin. Their pies and pastries are amazing. The best cakes I've ever had in the Setauket/Stony Brook area were from La Bonne Boulangerie.

CandB4604 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Thanks so much! :)

evewedsjc Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

i have had numerous caked from rolling pin..they have all been delicious...i just can't remember what kinds at the moment...lol
CandB4604 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

kay awesome! :)

CandB4604 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

I'm hopefully meeting with Rolling Pin on Saturday - he's calling me back to let me know if he's available.

Felice917 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Rolling Pin has fantastic cakes (tasty and beautiful), and Create a Cake is just so so. I have heard that it is difficult to get an appointment for Rolling Pin, but it is totally worth the wait. Good luck.

Coach416 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

My cake was from rolling pin. Everyone raved about it! I had chocolate cake with cookies and cream filling. I was sick so I didn't get to eat any that night, but I defrosted my top and had a slice two weeks later (I felt I was entitled to a slice before it was really disgusting) AND two weeks later it was the best cake I've ever had!!!!! I grew up on betty crocker cakes and have never liked bakery cakes. This though was awesome.......I highly recommend them!!!!!

laurak102476 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

My cake was from Rolling Pin and it was delicious!!!!

NapaValleyGirl Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Our cake was from Create a Cake and it was delicious and beautiful! It was red velvet as well. Most bakeries charge more for red velvet and fondant and they didn't.


MrsList09 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

I got my sweet 16 cake there and although it was just a regular sheet cake and nothing particularly fancy, we gave them a napkin we wanted to match to the cake and let me tell you, it was EXACTLY like the design on the napkin. So I don't know if that helps (it was also 12 years ago - WOW I'm old...) but we had a great experience with them.

CandB4604 Posted:

Re: Rolling Pin Bakery or Create-A-Cake?

Posted by abrennan01

I got my sweet 16 cake there and although it was just a regular sheet cake and nothing particularly fancy, we gave them a napkin we wanted to match to the cake and let me tell you, it was EXACTLY like the design on the napkin. So I don't know if that helps (it was also 12 years ago - WOW I'm old...) but we had a great experience with them.


are you talking about RP or CAC? (And thank you for letting me know in advance!) :)

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.