I am looking for a very good romantic restaurant to take my DH too. Any suggestions?
Kelly9904
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I like pasta pasta in Port Jeff, I will call it casual romantic. Its not dressy but its very dimly lit and hte food is good! My favorite is La Strada in Happauge (I think) Its on wheeler road. They are so amazingly nice, have wonderful food and a great wine selection. Every time we are there we are there for like 2 hours with firends and they never rush us! Again its not a really fancy romantic place but its my fave to go to with FH!
allure
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I agree with Pasta Pasta
ss2002
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I just had a great meal at Sweetwaters (on 111 in Hauppauge). I don't know if it was super-duper romantic, but it was very nice. Plus, they have an amazing chocolate fondue dessert...now that's romantic in my book!!
Nora101004
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I went to sweetwaters once it and was the worst meal we ever ate. My mom went there a few times and loved the food.
I'd recomend Celantro's in Bayport. It was so nice there.
casg
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Ciao Baby in commack
Kelly9904
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Oh, I liked ciao baby, Honestly I wouldnt call it romantic but they are or have opened one on Sunrise Highway in Massapequa (I see it from teh train)
Sweetwaters, very good, not romantic in my opinion! But now I have to go back for that chocolate foudue!
Stacey1403
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I agree ciao baby has excellent food, but it is way to cramped and crowded to be 'romantic'
I third pasta pasta
ss2002
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Couldn't remember the name before...
The Mill River Inn (Oyster Bay) is very good!!
Teri
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Mill River inn is excellent but very pricey. Rated in Zagats for best food on LI a few years ago.
where exactly on LI would you like to go?
Kathy116
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I had the worst food poisoning from Cilantro's in Bayport...I was hospitalized it was so bad!
halloweenbride04
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
The Country House in Stony Brook.
nylisa
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Every Valentine's Day FI and I go to 42 Woodcleft in Freeport.
jenny2penny
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
courtyard cafe in happague
Jenny5150
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I haven't been to it, but I'm dying to check out Tellers Chophouse in Islip.
Here's the Zagat review: A “cool converted bank” with “high ceilings, beautiful photos and a dark-wood cigar bar” is drawing interest in Islip in its current incarnation as a “shrine to meat”; also accounting for the attraction are “jumbo portions” of “incredible steaks and seafood”, all “cooked to perfection”, accompanied by “outstanding wines” cellared in a former “walk-in safe” as well as “wonderful service”; it’s certainly “pricey”, but “worth it” for such “unbelievable dining.”
Mazzi in Huntington
Zagat review: This “gem” is “one of the classiest eateries on the Island”, serving “sensational” Continental cuisine that’s both “inventive” and “delicious” in a “wonderfully romantic”, “candlelit” interior set in a “beautiful little old house” in Huntington Station; the “quick”, “accommodating” staff makes mavens feel positively “mayoral”, and though some say it’s “overpriced”, others counter “you get your money’s worth”; P.S. “love the jazz” trio on weekends.
Louis XVI in Patchogue
Zagat review: Loyal subjects are “transported to another time and place” at this waterfront “palace in Patchogue” with fluted columns and crystal chandeliers creating “surroundings fit for royalty” (it was voted the Survey’s No. 1 for Decor); “if you’re willing to pay Paris prices” (prix fixe or tasting menu) for “top-of-the-line” New French cuisine, then “dress to the nines” for an “extravagant” experience complete with “artful, delicious” fare, “a staff that could not be more accommodating” and a “fabulous view.”
Jordan
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Posted by Jenny5150
Mazzi in Huntington
Zagat review: This “gem” is “one of the classiest eateries on the Island”, serving “sensational” Continental cuisine that’s both “inventive” and “delicious” in a “wonderfully romantic”, “candlelit” interior set in a “beautiful little old house” in Huntington Station; the “quick”, “accommodating” staff makes mavens feel positively “mayoral”, and though some say it’s “overpriced”, others counter “you get your money’s worth”; P.S. “love the jazz” trio on weekends.
Excellent food - quaint atmosphere...very romantic. Very pricey - but, imo, very worth it.
Cindy
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
I second The Country House in Stony Brook. Also, Sempre Vivola in Happauge. We go every year for my Birthday.
Diane
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
Another vote for Pasta Pasta
janatlantica
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
LOVE the Country House and of corse, mi favorito, Trumpets on the Bay! Collins & Main in Sayvill is also very nice, as is the Bayport House in Bayport!
groovypeg
Posted:
Member since
Re: Romantic Restaurant on LI
butterfields in haupague is great!
here is what zagat had to say:
'Tucked away in an industrial park, this hard-to-find place is worth the trip” rave reviewers of this New American neophyte in Hauppauge that has “hit the ground running” with chef Jerry Suppa’s “innovative presentations”, “varied selections” and “wonderful” dishes; the “impeccable service”, “pretty” decor (some tables have loveseats) and “soothing” live jazz on Mondays and Fridays make for a “fine experience.”
i also just at at blue honu last thursday and i was very impressed with the food. it was seafood/hawaiian. it is in huntington.
