RP from 07: Need some help!!

FH and I have NO IDEA where to go for our honeymoon. He already said no to Hawaii (too far), Italy (too expensive and we don't have enough time), Fiji and Tahiti are out for the same reason as Italy), and he said no Mexico (not sure why but whatever) Sooooo, that leaves us with the caribbean. Now being that his dad works for American Airlines - he's pretty much flown to EVERY caribbean island almost. I on the otherhand have not since my family doesn' t fly. So far we've already been to Dominican Repulic, Bahamas, and St. Thomas together. Anyone have any other suggestions? We were thinking of Aruba, St. Lucia, Antigua, and possibly Barbados. He wants an all inclusive place and I don't want it to be too expensive (maybe around $2000?) Sorry so long - but I need some ideas desperately!

Thanks so much!