RP from 08: Which HM would you choose?

Since our original cruise was cancelled, we are back to square one regarding the HM. Thanks in advance!!! I am so darn indecisive!

We still want to do a cruise, (preferably with princess since Travel Toms said he would probably be able to get us onboard credit and an upgrade because of our cancellation. However, the other day while talking about the HM a commerical came on about Atlantis in the Bahamas. FH has always wanted to go there, so i'm trying to work it in our budget. We dropped our HM budget to 4000 since we really want to save for a condo/house now.. These are the options I found and priced before bother Trael Tom, so maybe can always get cheaper.so here are the options: Oh and please tell me your opinions :)

Option 1: (about 3900)
7 night Princess cruise out of PR (our original cruise only now in December rather than January.
It goes to Barbados, St. Lucia, Antigua, Tortola, ans St. Thomas. Then we would fly to Nassau for 4 days.

Option 2: (about 3800)
10 night Princess cruise out of Fort Lauderdale. We would fly in the night before. The cruise goes to: Princess Cays Bahamas, St. Thomas, St. Kitts, Barbados, St. Lucia and Antigua. Since this cruise is longer we would not go to Atlantis.

Option 3: (About 3800)
6 night Royal Caribbean cruise of of Fort Lauderdale. It goes to Belize, Costa Maya and Cozume. Again, we would go to Atlanits for 4 days after.

Option 4: (4100)
9 Day Norweigan cruise out of Miami. It goes to Samana, Tortola, Antigua, Barbados, and St. Lucia. We would go to Atlantis for 4 days after.

i like the islands in the first one best....you are getting a nice sampling of the caribbean.

whatever you chose---i would definitely want to make it to atlantis. i had friends who went there and they said it was just amazing.

I chose Option 4, b/c your still getting to go to some places you would go with any of the other options, like Antigua. I have always wanted to go there and i have a friend who is Antiguan and she always talks about it, makes me want to go, so i voted for that.

Then I figured its your damn HM, why not stay as long as you can lol If you can work it out where you can get a cruise, for as long as the 9 days, AND still go to Atlantis..I think that would work out perfectly!

I choose # 4 all the way. =D

Thanks girls!

I've gone on several cruises already, and the best one, by far, was Norwegian.
It is free style cruising, so you get to eat whenever, whatever, however many times, wear whatever you want.

Go to the art auctions - free champagne and nice art (even if you're not buying, it's nice to see)
And don't purchase the land tours/activities on the ship b/c the ship takes a cut, so you'll get a much better deal when you get off the ship.

Happy Cruising