RP from BHB: BM dress... opinions please!

Happy 2006 girls!

I love love this bridesmaid dress:

BM Dress 1:



Do you think it will go well with my dress? Does it look too poofy? One of my BM thinks its a bit too fancy. Should I look for something simpler? Something like this, but in the same color as above:

BM Dress 2:


This is my wedding dress:



Side picture of bustle from WC's crazy4trev:


Thanks!