sonia- wish bowl question

i know that you did the wish bowl and the guest book. how did that work out? do you think it was redundant?

i want to do both too. i was thinking of having the wish bowl for comments/advice/whatever that we can open up on our 1st or 5th anniversary. i think the 10th anniversary would be cute to look at the notes but i know i won't be able to wait that long.