Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Original post by FeliciaDA

Nov 12, 2004 03:06 PM

I know I have a few crushes on people that most of you would probably go 'eeeeeuw' if you knew about them

And my husband has crushes on certain celebs where I just don't see the appeal (i.e., Lisa Loeb )

So who do you have a crush on that normally you wouldn't consider handsome or beautiful in an obvious way?

ETA: I'll start. I think Tobey Maguire is cute in a very nerdy sort of way

Dooodles Posted: Nov 13, 2004 08:11 AM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by btrflygrl

Tobey Maguire
Rob Thomas (lead singer of Matchbox20)

Oh, I am right there with you on the Rob Thomas thing big time. Although it is his voice that I find unbelievably sexy!
I also have to add, no matter how old he gets, Robert Redford will always melt my insides!

Summerbride04 Posted: Nov 13, 2004 08:43 AM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Neal McDonough from that new show Medical Investigations. Love him and the show!

1735482_1.jpg

DMAG Posted: Nov 13, 2004 12:29 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Lisa Loeb and Ashleigh Banfield

GLASSES...MMMMM! I think I have a librarian fetish.

Jenn524 Posted: Nov 13, 2004 02:48 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Kevin James is too cute.

I also love Paul Reiser and Chris Meloni.

cocoa Posted: Nov 13, 2004 02:56 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by janwinterbridejoy

i have two the first im sure some of you ladies are going to scream lol. but there is somthing about him that is soooo hot the second is my actor gary oldman i met him when he was filming romeo is bleeding and he just is sooo cute

JK

i kind of have a thing for owen wilson! his broken nose is quirky, but his sense of humor and his voice crack me up!

1735999_1.jpg

slwh2005 Posted: Nov 13, 2004 06:44 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by DMAG

Lisa Loeb and Ashleigh Banfield

GLASSES...MMMMM! I think I have a librarian fetish.

Hey!! I'm a librarian.

slwh2005 Posted: Nov 13, 2004 06:47 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

I've always had a thing for Edward Norton ever since he was in Primal Fear. I guess he's not that unconventional though since Salma Hayek used to date him.

1736195_1.jpg

Jenn524 Posted: Nov 14, 2004 11:16 AM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Edward Norton is so hot in American History X. When he's kneeling in the street in just his boxers.

slwh2005 Posted: Nov 14, 2004 12:22 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by Jenn524

Edward Norton is so hot in American History X. When he's kneeling in the street in just his boxers.

I haven't seen that movie yet! Ooooh - it sounds like a good one! Thanks. Love him!!

Jenn524 Posted: Nov 14, 2004 12:40 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

The movie itself is a little hard to watch. It's an excellent movie and I found it to be very powerful.

But Edward Norton is HOT in it.

cocoa Posted: Nov 14, 2004 01:19 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

be prepared with american history x...it isn't for the light of heart!

[email protected] Posted: Nov 14, 2004 01:32 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

John Cusack!

jj04 Posted: Nov 15, 2004 02:27 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by FeliciaDA

I know I have a few crushes on people that most of you would probably go 'eeeeeuw' if you knew about them

And my husband has crushes on certain celebs where I just don't see the appeal (i.e., Lisa Loeb )

So who do you have a crush on that normally you wouldn't consider handsome or beautiful in an obvious way?

ETA: I'll start. I think Tobey Maguire is cute in a very nerdy sort of way

i always thought Lisa Loeb was pretty too...that is funny. I love Kevin James...he is adorable

jennandrob Posted: Nov 15, 2004 02:57 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

A lot of poeple say his head is too big, but
call me crazy, I've got a thing for Peyton Manning, the QB for the Colts.

1739914_1.jpg

Johnny&Maur Posted: Nov 15, 2004 02:58 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by [email protected]

John Cusack!

I love John Cusack too!!

And i find John Cryer adorable too...'ducky' from Sixteen Candles :)

didianita Posted: Nov 15, 2004 02:58 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by [email protected]

John Cusack!

Me 2!

Donna Posted: Nov 15, 2004 03:27 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

I have a 'crush' on Ed Harris from Stepmom and tons of other movies

Katherine121 Posted: Nov 15, 2004 03:47 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by Janice

Eric!!!
I don't know why I just do...

LOL!! My mom has a crush on him too.

littlewilson Posted: Nov 15, 2004 04:07 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

Posted by janwinterbridejoy

...the second is my actor gary oldman i met him when he was filming romeo is bleeding and he just is sooo cute

I can't believe only one person has mentioned Gary Oldman so far! He's unquestionably one of the sexiest men alive...well, to me anyway!

So jealous you met him.

divabride Posted: Nov 15, 2004 04:34 PM

Re: Spinoff of crushes: which celebrity do you have a crush on that is, to put it nicely, 'unconventional looking'

I have a major crush on Anthony Michael Hall. He's been in weird science, pretty in pink, breakfast club. Hes in the dead zone now, and I have the major hots for him. FH thinks hes a dork.